For regular, thorough cleaning of floors, carpets and furniture, start by comparing cylinder vacuum cleaners: UFC-Que Choisir distinguishes them from cordless stick vacuums for longer cleaning sessions. A cordless stick vacuum is better suited to quick clean-ups and moving around without a cable, provided its battery life on the setting you use and its accessories meet your needs. A handheld vacuum is mainly for small areas as a supplementary cleaner.
The scale of the clean and the surfaces you need to reach matter more than the type’s name alone.
If you regularly clean floors, carpets or rugs and furniture with one main appliance, start by comparing cylinder vacuum cleaners and their floorheads. UFC-Que Choisir highlights their suction performance, while noting that they are less manoeuvrable than cordless stick vacuums.
A cordless stick vacuum is easy to grab and move around without managing a cable. It’s a good choice if manoeuvrability is your priority, but check the battery life on the setting you’ll need for your carpets before relying on it as your only vacuum cleaner.
A handheld vacuum, or a stick vacuum with compatible accessories, can help you clean seats, upholstery and awkward corners. It’s best viewed as a complement to floor cleaning rather than an immediate replacement for a main vacuum cleaner.
Start with the surfaces you need to clean and how long your usual cleaning session lasts. Then check how the vacuum is emptied and what accessories come with the exact model you’re considering.
| What to consider | What to check | What I need |
|---|---|---|
| Floors and carpets | Check which floorhead is supplied for each floor type and, where possible, look for pick-up tests carried out on comparable surfaces. Motor wattage or a single suction figure alone won’t tell you how well the vacuum will perform on your carpet. | I switch between hard floors and carpet, so I need a floorhead that works on both, especially if my carpet is thick. UFC-Que Choisir notes that stick vacuums may perform less well than cylinder models on thick carpets and rugs. |
| Length of cleaning session | For a cordless stick vacuum, compare battery life on the setting you’ll use and check whether the battery can be replaced on the model you’re considering. | If I clean several rooms without stopping, battery life on the highest power setting matters more than the maximum figure advertised. UFC-Que Choisir says that stick vacuums average around ten minutes of battery life at full power. |
| Bag or bin | Check how the bag is removed or the bin emptied, as well as what’s involved in cleaning the filters. Consider the capacity in relation to how often you clean. | I’d rather dispose of dust in a bag, or I’m happy to empty and clean a bin regularly. How easy this is will matter just as much as the stated capacity. |
| Furniture and awkward corners | Check which nozzles and brushes are included and whether they’re compatible with the exact model. A flexible hose or extension is only useful if it’s included with the model you choose. | To reach seats, upholstery and tight spaces, I want to know exactly which accessories come with the vacuum. |
| Manoeuvrability and maintenance | Compare the weight you’ll need to move around, whether there’s a cable and how much storage space you’ll need. Also check how to clean the bin, filters and brushes. | A vacuum that’s quick to grab will help with smaller clean-ups. For a longer session, I may be happy with a cylinder model if it’s practical to move around my home. |
Cordless models make quick clean-ups easier, but battery life at high power can limit longer sessions covering carpets and several rooms. UFC-Que Choisir therefore distinguishes between quick touch-ups and deep cleaning.
Estimate the areas you need to clean in one go. If you choose a stick vacuum, check its battery life on the setting you plan to use and whether the battery can be replaced.
An advertised figure doesn’t tell you how well a vacuum will pick up dust from your floors or carpets. The floorhead you use also affects the comparison.
Check which brushes are included and, if pick-up performance is a priority, compare tests carried out on the same type of surface using a comparable method.
You may need a crevice tool or an upholstery brush to reach furniture and seats. Dyson notes, for example, that accessory kit compatibility depends on the product range.
Before choosing a vacuum for the car or upholstery, check what’s in the box and the compatibility list for the complete model number.
Cleaning a bin, filter or brush adds regular jobs to your cleaning routine. ADEME points out that maintaining a vacuum cleaner helps extend its useful life.
Before choosing, check how to access the filters and brush, and which consumables or spare parts are compatible with the model.
These examples of product ranges can help you identify features to check. They don’t represent every model from each brand.
In France, Miele offers bagged cylinder vacuum cleaners designed to be used as a main appliance.
Rowenta’s French range includes cordless stick vacuums and handheld models for jobs of different sizes.
Dyson offers cordless vacuum cleaners and kits designed for tasks such as cleaning cars and upholstery.
These options include corded and cordless stick vacuums, a bagged cylinder vacuum and a bagless vacuum cleaner. Compare their design and features with your floors, carpets and furniture before choosing.
Image unavailable
Worth considering if you want to move from floors to carpets without stopping to recharge a battery. The product listing states 65 kPa and 600 W; these figures don’t replace a pick-up test on your own flooring. Check which brushes are included if you plan to clean furniture and upholstery.
Image unavailable
The cordless design is handy when freedom of movement is a priority. The listing claims up to 65 minutes of battery life and 60.000 Pa. Check which setting that battery-life figure applies to, especially if you use a higher-power setting on carpets. Also check which accessories are included for furniture or car cleaning.
Image unavailable
This cordless stick vacuum is an option for frequent clean-ups around the home. The product listing claims 45 minutes of battery life and 55000 Pa, but these figures don’t indicate how it will perform on carpets or how long the battery will last on the setting you use. Also check which accessories are included for furniture or car cleaning.
Image unavailable
This corded, bagged model is worth comparing for regular cleaning across several floor types, particularly if you’d rather remove a bag than empty a bin. Check which brushes and nozzles are included for your carpets and furniture, and look for pick-up tests for this model.
Image unavailable
Worth a look if you’re happy to empty and clean a bin rather than use bags. The product name suggests a cylinder vacuum, but the details about its design don’t match up. Check the exact configuration, the included floorhead and whether it’s suitable for your carpets before choosing.
Not if you also need to clean furniture, high-up areas or the car by hand. For these jobs, choose a vacuum cleaner with suitable accessories. A robot vacuum is designed for a different task: automated floor cleaning.
Because the maximum battery life advertised may not reflect how long it will run at high power. UFC-Que Choisir says that stick vacuums average around ten minutes at full power, so compare battery life on the setting you plan to use on your carpets.
Check for a crevice tool and an accessory suitable for upholstery or seats. Make sure they’re included and compatible with the exact model. Dyson, for example, notes that some of its kits only fit specific product ranges.
Yes, if a repairability index is shown for the models you’re comparing. ADEME describes it as a way to help you choose an appliance that can be repaired if it breaks down. Also check which parts are available and what maintenance each model requires.