For everyday mess, choose a rechargeable stick vacuum if you’re happy to check how long the battery lasts in the mode you’ll use. For larger homes and regular cleaning of floors, furniture and upholstery, a cylinder vacuum is often a better fit. A robot can help keep floors clean, but it won’t necessarily replace a manual vacuum.
If you mainly clean up small messes, furniture or stairs, an easy-to-grab appliance may suit you best. UFC-Que Choisir’s guide describes stick vacuums as a handy extra, while also highlighting their limited battery life.
If your cleaning sessions regularly cover a large area, carpets, hard floors and upholstery, look at battery life or runtime and the accessories included. UFC-Que Choisir describes cylinder vacuums as particularly well suited to larger homes.
If you’d like to schedule some of your cleaning, a robot vacuum is worth considering, as long as you take obstacles, emptying and brush cleaning into account. UFC-Que Choisir notes that its results depend, among other things, on the type of floor.
Best for: quick, targeted clean-ups, when being able to grab your vacuum quickly matters more than tackling a long cleaning session in one go.
The trade-off: according to UFC-Que Choisir, battery life and suction power can be limited. The maximum advertised runtime may not reflect how long the vacuum lasts in the mode you’ll use.
Best for: a main vacuum for regular cleaning across larger areas and different floor types.
The trade-off: the cable and moving the vacuum around take up more space and require more effort. A bagged model also needs compatible bags.
Worth considering: for scheduled cleaning on floors the robot can access.
The trade-off: results vary depending on the floor and surroundings, according to UFC-Que Choisir. You’ll still need to maintain the dust container, brushes and, where applicable, the docking station.
| What matters | What to check | Who it’s for |
|---|---|---|
| Quick clean-ups | Compare how easy the stick vacuum is to store and recharge, then check its runtime in the mode you plan to use. | I often want to tackle small messes without a lot of preparation, so I need to be able to grab the vacuum quickly. Around 40% of consumers prioritise this kind of quick clean-up. |
| Thorough cleaning | Check the cleaning reach and whether the brushes are suited to your floors and upholstery. Don’t judge suction by the motor’s wattage alone. | When I need to clean floors, carpets and furniture in one session, uninterrupted use is my priority. Thorough cleaning comes first for around 40% of consumers. |
| Automated floor cleaning | Check thresholds, carpets, obstacles and what’s involved in emptying the vacuum. | If I want to cut down on regular manual cleaning, I need to be able to let the robot move around freely and maintain it afterwards. Around 20% of consumers put this kind of automation at the top of their list. |
UFC-Que Choisir explains that the maximum advertised runtime is measured at the lowest power setting, and that average runtime at full power is around ten minutes. A longer clean in a more demanding mode may therefore be interrupted by recharging.
Compare runtimes in the mode you plan to use and check whether a compatible replacement battery is available for the exact model you’re considering.
Electrical power alone doesn’t tell you how well a vacuum will perform on your floors. UFC-Que Choisir also highlights the importance of the floorhead, accessories and manoeuvrability.
Look for brushes and nozzles suited to your floors and upholstery, then consider how easy the vacuum is to move around.
A bagged cylinder vacuum needs compatible bags, while bagless models and robot vacuums need to be emptied and cleaned. A robot’s docking station doesn’t eliminate these tasks.
Before choosing between a bag, dust container and docking station, check the compatible consumables and the maintenance steps for the model you’re considering.
UFC-Que Choisir found that mopping results can be inconsistent and advises against robot mopping on solid wood floors in its test protocol.
Identify your floor types and follow the guidance from both the floor and appliance manufacturers before using the mopping function.
Worth considering if access to parts and repairs is important when choosing a stick, cylinder or robot vacuum.
Worth considering, particularly for a cordless stick vacuum, if you want to identify the parts that fit your appliance.
Worth a look if you’re after a bagged cylinder vacuum and reach and a hard-floor brush are priorities.
Worth considering if scheduling and automating some of your floor cleaning are priorities.
This selection includes bagged cylinder vacuums for bigger cleans and stick vacuums for quick, targeted pick-ups. The MONSGA HQ1 is a corded stick vacuum: you won’t need to recharge it, but you will need a power socket. Compare each appliance based on your surfaces and how you plan to use it.
Image unavailable
Worth considering for cleaning sessions across several floor types, when operating radius and the brushes included matter to you.
Image unavailable
Worth comparing for cleaning different surfaces if you’re looking for a cylinder vacuum with a dedicated parquet brush.
Image unavailable
Worth considering for cleaning floors and upholstery if you’d rather plug in than recharge a battery.
Image unavailable
Worth considering for quick, targeted clean-ups if you’d also like to convert the stick vacuum into a handheld.
Image unavailable
Worth comparing for targeted cleaning on hard floors and carpets if you’d like a stick vacuum that can also be used as a handheld.
Yes, if its runtime in the mode you need is long enough for your home, but don’t rely on the maximum advertised runtime alone. UFC-Que Choisir says this is measured at the lowest power setting and reports an average runtime of around ten minutes at full power. Also check whether the battery can be replaced on the model you choose.
Not necessarily. A robot can clean floors by itself, but results vary depending on the surfaces, according to UFC-Que Choisir. If you also need to clean furniture, upholstery or hard-to-reach areas, keep a suitable manual vacuum on hand.
Check that the brushes suit your floor types, look at the operating radius and find out which bags and filters are compatible. If you’d rather avoid bags, compare how easy it is to empty and clean the dust container on a bagless model.
Yes. According to the DGCCRF, corded, cordless and robot vacuum cleaners are among the categories covered in France. The repairability rating tells you about how easy the model is to repair, not how well it vacuums. Consider it alongside the accessories and features that matter to you.
Avoid doing so: UFC-Que Choisir advises against robot mopping on solid wood floors in its test protocol. For any other wood flooring, check the guidance from both the flooring manufacturer and the robot manufacturer before switching on this function.