For a long cleaning session across several floor types, a cylinder vacuum cleaner is generally less limited by battery life, although you’ll need to consider its cable and the effort involved in moving the body of the machine. A cordless stick vacuum can be your main appliance if its performance on your floors and its runtime in the mode you need are enough to cover the whole session. Otherwise, it can complement a main vacuum. Que Choisir recommends comparing performance across different surfaces and usage conditions.
If you clean hard floors, rugs and furniture, compare performance on each surface and check that the right accessories are included. Que Choisir’s test protocols assess suction on different types of flooring, among other things.
If you want to clean several rooms without stopping, check the runtime in the mode you’ll actually need for a cordless stick vacuum, or the capacity and reach of a cylinder vacuum.
If you’ll need to move the appliance around during a long cleaning session, consider how much effort it takes to carry, push or pull the model, as well as how often you’ll need to change plug sockets. Que Choisir highlights the different handling considerations for cordless stick and cylinder vacuums.
Que Choisir’s guides and test protocols assess performance across different floor types and the compromises involved in everyday use. If you’re choosing a main appliance for several surfaces or a large area, compare these criteria with the layout and needs of your home.
Worth considering: for a long cleaning session if you’d rather replace a bag than empty a dust container.
Bear in mind: bags are consumables, and you’ll need to pull the body of the appliance along and manage the cable.
Worth considering: if you’d rather not buy bags and don’t mind emptying the dust container and maintaining the filters.
Bear in mind: emptying it may expose you to dust, so check that you’re comfortable with this.
Worth considering: if its performance on your floors and runtime in the mode you need are sufficient for your cleaning session.
Bear in mind: the maximum advertised runtime may not match the runtime you’ll get in the setting you need, particularly on rugs.
Worth considering: if you want one appliance for a thorough clean and another that’s easy to grab between sessions.
Bear in mind: two appliances need more storage space, and both require maintenance.
| What matters | What to check | Who will value this most? |
|---|---|---|
| Performance on different floor types and furniture | Compare test results for the exact model on each type of flooring and check that it includes the brushes you need. | When I need to clean several types of flooring and furniture in the same session, I want to check performance on each rather than rely on the wattage alone. Around 33% of consumers put this criterion first. |
| Finishing a full cleaning session | For a cordless stick vacuum, check the runtime in the mode you need; for a cylinder vacuum, look at the bag or dust container capacity and its reach. | To avoid interrupting my cleaning, I compare useful runtime or how often I’ll need to empty the container or change plug sockets. Around 27% of consumers prioritise cleaning without interruption. |
| Ease of handling and noise levels | Check the weight of the whole appliance you’ll be moving, how easy the floorhead is to manoeuvre, its reach and the stated noise level. | If I need to carry or move the appliance from room to room, the effort involved matters just as much as freedom of movement. Around 20% of consumers prioritise ease of handling. |
| Emptying and maintenance | Compare replacing a bag with emptying a dust container, and check the product codes for filters, bags and any parts you may need. | To minimise contact with dust and choose a maintenance routine that suits me, I check how the bag or dust container is emptied. Around 20% of consumers prioritise maintenance and avoiding contact with dust. |
The power rating alone doesn’t show how well a vacuum can remove dust from a rug or another type of flooring.
Compare test results on the floors in your home and check which brushes are included with the exact model.
The maximum advertised runtime is generally measured on the lowest setting; cleaning rugs may require a different mode.
Compare the runtimes for each mode with your usual cleaning session, and check the product code for a compatible replacement battery if this is important to your choice.
You’ll need to empty the dust container and maintain the filters, and emptying it may bring you into contact with dust. A bagged model, meanwhile, needs compatible bags.
Compare the maintenance instructions and check whether emptying a container or replacing a bag suits you for the exact model.
The listings consulted for the Electrolux Pure D8 PD82-4ST differ on the filtration specified: HEPA on Electrolux’s French product page and EPA E12 on a Joybuy listing.
Before comparing or buying, ask for confirmation of the full filter reference and the accessories included with the version on offer.
Bagged and bagless cylinder vacuums let you compare two different dust collection systems across separate models.
The ProAnimal BGS41PET1 bagless cylinder vacuum is worth comparing if you’d rather avoid buying bags.
The bagged Pure D8 PD82-4ST lets you look at the stated noise level, operating radius and accessories.
The cordless V11 Advanced is worth considering as a main stick vacuum if its useful runtime and performance suit your cleaning needs.
The Complete C3 125 Edition is an example of a bagged cylinder vacuum with accessories for furniture and cushions.
This selection includes bagged and bagless cylinder vacuums, as well as corded and cordless stick vacuums. Compare them based on your floor types and the length of your cleaning session.
Image unavailable
Worth comparing if you’re looking for a bagged cylinder vacuum for a full cleaning session. Check the performance and accessories of the exact version against your floor types.
Image unavailable
Worth comparing if you prefer a bagless cylinder vacuum. Check the capacity and accessories of the version on offer to make sure they suit your needs.
The product name specifies LED lighting and 900 W of power.
Image unavailable
Worth considering if you’re looking for a corded appliance that converts into a handheld vacuum. Check that its configuration is suitable for a full cleaning session.
The product name specifies 600 W, 15 kPa and a body weight of 2.2 kg. The floor brush is listed as having 180° swivel.
The product information states that it can’t be used to vacuum liquids.
Image unavailable
Worth comparing if you’re looking for a corded stick vacuum with a handheld function. It’s described as suitable for small spaces, so check whether it’s right for a full cleaning session.
The product name specifies 550 W of power, a 0.5 L dust container and a 4.5 m cable.
Image unavailable
Worth comparing if freedom of movement is a priority. Check the advertised runtime against the mode you need and the length of your cleaning session.
The product name specifies 18 kPa, an LED display and up to 40 minutes of advertised runtime.
The instructions say not to vacuum liquids, flammable substances or burning materials.
Yes, if its performance on all your floor types and its runtime in the mode you need are enough to cover your actual cleaning session. The maximum advertised runtime, usually measured on the lowest setting, isn’t enough to make a decision.
Empty or replace the dust collection system, and maintain the filters and brushes according to the instructions for your model. ADEME specifically advises against vacuuming plaster with a domestic appliance that isn’t designed for it.
Look up the compatible product codes for your chosen model, particularly for bags, filters or the battery, and check the maintenance instructions for the exact version.
According to the French Ministry of the Economy, a repairability index out of 10 is mandatory for vacuum cleaners. It indicates how repairable a product is, not how well it vacuums. The ministry explains that the durability index, which has replaced certain indices since 2025, applies to televisions and washing machines, not vacuum cleaners.
If it still works, you could consider donating it or passing it on for reuse. Otherwise, ADEME suggests options including returning it to a retailer or taking it to the dedicated electrical and electronic equipment skip at a recycling centre.