For short, frequent cleaning sessions, choose a stick vacuum if its runtime on the setting you need is enough for your home. A cylinder vacuum is better suited to deep cleaning larger areas and different floor types, provided you’re happy to deal with the cord and find somewhere to store it. A robot can take care of some day-to-day floor cleaning, but its performance and maintenance requirements mean you shouldn’t assume it will replace a manual vacuum.
If you regularly get the vacuum out for a quick clean, ease of use and storage may matter more than the advertised maximum runtime. UFC-Que Choisir generally recommends stick vacuums for this kind of quick clean.
For a large area, rugs or upholstery, look at cleaning performance on different floor types, as well as the supplied floorhead and accessories. UFC-Que Choisir presents cylinder vacuums as an option for this kind of thorough clean.
A robot can clean on a schedule if you’re happy to keep an eye on its navigation, empty its bins and maintain its brushes. UFC-Que Choisir notes that performance varies depending on the floor type.
Start by choosing the type that suits the task you have in mind. UFC-Que Choisir’s guides distinguish between quick cleans, thorough cleaning and automated cleaning, each with its own limitations.
Worth considering: if you want to grab your vacuum quickly for short, frequent cleaning sessions.
Bear in mind: runtime depends on the setting you need, particularly on surfaces that are harder to clean.
Worth considering: for a thorough clean across a large area, with different floor types or upholstery.
Bear in mind: it can be bulkier to move and store, and you’ll need to use a cord.
Worth considering: to automate some of your regular floor cleaning.
Bear in mind: you’ll still need to prepare your rooms and maintain the vacuum, even when cleaning is scheduled.
| Criteria | What to check | Who it suits |
|---|---|---|
| Quick cleans | Ease of use and storage; runtime on the setting you use. | If I often clean up small spills, I want to be able to get the vacuum out and put it away without effort. Around 40% of consumers would prioritise this quick access above all else. |
| Thorough cleaning | Performance on different floor types; floorhead and upholstery accessories. | If I clean a large area with rugs or upholstery, I want a vacuum suited to each area, even if it’s less easy to move around. Thorough cleaning would be the priority for around 40% of consumers. |
| Automated cleaning | Performance on floors, in corners and along edges; bin and brush maintenance. | I want to cut down on regular manual cleaning, while still having time to maintain the vacuum. This would be the main priority for around 20% of consumers. |
This runtime is generally measured on a low-power setting. It may not reflect how long the vacuum will last when cleaning rugs or very dirty areas, as UFC-Que Choisir points out.
Compare the runtime on the setting you plan to use with the length of your cleaning sessions, and check how long the model takes to charge.
A wattage figure on its own doesn’t tell you how well a vacuum will clean wooden floors, tiles, rugs or crevices. UFC-Que Choisir assesses performance across different floor types and takes the vacuum’s design into account.
Look for test results on the floors in your home and check which floorhead and accessories are actually included.
Bagged models need their bags replaced regularly. Maintenance also depends on the filters and which replacement parts are compatible.
Before choosing a bagged or bagless cylinder vacuum, check the product codes for consumables and the model’s maintenance instructions.
Scheduling doesn’t eliminate the need to empty the bin or clean the brushes. UFC-Que Choisir also notes that performance can vary from one floor type to another.
Check how it performs on your rugs, along edges and in corners. Also check app compatibility and, if included, how to maintain the docking station.
The X-Force Flex range includes stick vacuums worth considering for frequent cleaning, depending on the model’s features.
Miele offers bagged cylinder vacuums with different filter and nozzle configurations for thorough cleaning.
Dyson offers cordless stick vacuums and bagless models to compare based on your floors and the accessories you need.
Electrolux offers both bagged cylinder vacuums and stick vacuums, so you can compare the two types based on how you’ll use yours most.
These models cover three different needs: a cylinder vacuum for thorough cleaning, two stick vacuums for frequent cleaning and a robot to automate some floor care. Compare their specifications with how they perform on your floors before making your choice.
Image unavailable
Worth considering if thorough cleaning with a cylinder vacuum is your priority. Check that the supplied brushes suit your floors and upholstery, and find out which replacement bags are compatible.
Image unavailable
Its cordless design makes it suited to short, frequent cleaning sessions. The product listing says it can stand upright on its own. Check its runtime on the setting you need and how it performs on your floors, rather than relying on the advertised maximum runtime alone.
Image unavailable
Worth considering for short cleaning sessions if you like the freestanding design. The product listing states that it has a removable battery and runs for up to 60 minutes. Check which setting this runtime applies to before comparing it with your needs.
Image unavailable
Worth considering if you want to schedule some floor cleaning alongside your manual cleaning routine. The product listing describes an OMNI station and a mopping function. Check how it performs on your rugs and in corners, make sure the app is compatible, and find out what maintenance is still required.
No. On its own, it won’t tell you how well a vacuum will perform on every floor type. For cylinder vacuums, UFC-Que Choisir recommends looking at factors such as the floorhead and performance on different surfaces. You should also check that the accessories are suitable for your home.
Compare how long they run on the setting you’ll use, not just their maximum runtime. UFC-Que Choisir says maximum runtime is generally measured on the lowest setting; its tests report an average of around ten minutes at full power for the stick vacuums tested.
Yes. Check the index for the exact model rather than relying on the brand’s reputation. The French Ministry of the Economy says that vacuum cleaners covered by the French requirement must display a repairability score out of 10, based in particular on criteria relating to documentation, disassembly and spare parts.
Not in every case. First, consider whether it can automate some of your floor cleaning. UFC-Que Choisir reports that performance varies depending on the floor type. Before deciding whether it meets your other cleaning needs, also check how it handles edges and corners, and what’s involved in maintaining the bin and brushes.