Choose a cordless stick vacuum to pick up mess straight away in a particular spot, on the stairs or along the skirting boards. You’ll need to handle it yourself and keep an eye on its battery life. A robot vacuum is a better fit if you want to schedule regular cleaning, provided you prepare the space and maintain the machine. If you’re also considering mopping, check how it handles rugs and reserve this feature for light upkeep on hard floors. Don’t assume it replaces a deep clean.
If you need to pick up a few bits near the entrance or clean a particular area, a cordless stick vacuum lets you get started without scheduling a cycle. UFC-Que Choisir describes it as a handy option for everyday touch-ups, while reminding shoppers to consider its battery life.
A robot vacuum is a good choice if you’d like to delegate regular cleaning and can leave its docking station in place. You’ll also need to make time to empty the dustbin and maintain the brushes. For connected features, check the app’s terms of use too.
A robot mop can combine picking up small bits of debris with light wet cleaning. This feature means you’ll also need to manage the mop pads and water. It doesn’t, on its own, mean that a deep clean is no longer necessary.
To choose between a stick vacuum and a robot, start with the task you want to delegate — or tackle straight away. Then consider your floors and the maintenance you’re happy to do after each clean.
Choose this if: you want to clean a specific area, the stairs or an edge straight away.
The trade-off: you’ll need to guide the vacuum each time and make sure it’s charged.
Choose this if: you want to schedule regular cleaning in a space that’s clear enough for it to move around.
The trade-off: you’ll need to set up its docking station, prepare its route and maintain the parts that collect dirt.
Choose this if: you mainly want to keep hard floors clean and would also like a light wet clean.
The trade-off: the mop pads and tanks need maintenance; this feature doesn’t mean a deep clean is unnecessary.
| What to consider | What to check | Who it matters to |
|---|---|---|
| Quick clean-ups | How easy it is to pick up and use, reach specific areas and empty the dustbin. | When a few bits of dirt appear, I want to pick them up without having to prepare a room. Around 33% of consumers would put this ability to clean up straight away at the top of their list. |
| Floor types and battery life | Results on your different floor coverings and battery life in the mode you’ll use; for a robot, check how it cleans along edges and in corners. | With rugs and hard floors at home, I want to know what the vacuum picks up on each surface, rather than relying on the stated run time alone. Around 27% of consumers would make this versatility their priority. |
| Scheduling | The model’s features, network compatibility and the permissions requested by the app. | If I can’t guide the vacuum each time, I’d rather schedule regular cleaning cycles. For around 27% of consumers, scheduling would be the main priority. |
| Light mopping | Water settings, how it handles rugs, and how to maintain the mop pads and tanks. | On hard floors, I’d like to add a light wet clean between full cleans, without expecting a deep clean. Around 13% of consumers would prioritise this. |
UFC-Que Choisir assesses stick vacuums separately for suction, battery life and ease of use. Its testing for robot vacuums looks at different floor types, as well as edges and corners. These criteria are more useful when comparing individual models than relying on a single advertised feature.
Run time doesn’t tell you how well the vacuum performs on your floor coverings, or how long it lasts in the mode you need. UFC-Que Choisir also looks at charging, noise and maintenance.
Check which mode the stated run time applies to, and look for suction test results on the types of floor you clean.
Mapping, scheduling and remote control may depend on the app and Wi-Fi. The set-up instructions from Ecovacs and Dreame show that requirements vary by device and configuration.
Read the instructions for the model you’re considering, check your network and review the permissions requested by the app. The CNIL also recommends considering privacy when using connected devices.
The presence of a mop pad or water tank doesn’t prove how well a robot will clean your home. UFC-Que Choisir treats the results of robot mops as something to check, rather than an automatic result of the advertised feature.
Check how the model handles rugs, how you can adjust the water and how to clean its mop pads.
Depending on the model, you may also need to fill and clean the tank, maintain the docking station and replace the mop pads or other consumables.
A vacuum that’s used often needs to provide easy access to its filters and brushes. In France, the government departments responsible for the ecological transition say that vacuum cleaners are among the products covered by the repairability index.
Compare the index shown for the exact model and check that the right spare parts and instructions are available.
These brands are useful reference points when comparing specific robot vacuums. They don’t guarantee that every model has the same features.
UFC-Que Choisir lists Rowenta among established robot vacuum brands.
iRobot is one of the robot vacuum brands mentioned in UFC-Que Choisir’s guide.
UFC-Que Choisir lists Ecovacs among the key players in the robot vacuum market.
Roborock is also listed among the robot vacuum brands in UFC-Que Choisir’s guide.
Dreame is among the robot vacuum brands mentioned by UFC-Que Choisir.
This selection includes cordless stick vacuums for targeted clean-ups and robot mops for scheduled cleaning and light upkeep on hard floors. Compare how each model fits your needs, based on the tasks you actually want it to handle.
Image unavailable
For picking up dirt in specific areas without scheduling a clean. The product listing states that it has a removable battery, a self-standing design and up to 60 minutes of run time. Check which mode this figure applies to, and don’t use this dry vacuum to pick up liquids.
Image unavailable
Worth considering for targeted cleaning on hard floors and rugs: the title mentions a charging dock and 55 minutes of run time. Check the version being sold before ordering, as the description also mentions MV03. Make sure to check the run time in the mode you’ll use too.
Image unavailable
For combining automated cleaning with light wet cleaning on hard floors. The title mentions an OMNI station and mop pad washing at a stated 75 °C. Before choosing this model, check the space needed for the station, app compatibility and how to maintain the tanks.
Image unavailable
For cleaning a small area yourself and standing the vacuum up between jobs. The title states that it runs for up to 45 minutes and has an anti-tangle brush. Check which mode this run time applies to, and don’t use it to pick up liquids or clean wet surfaces.
Image unavailable
For regular cleaning with vacuuming and light mopping, if you have space to leave the station set up. The title mentions laser navigation and hot-air drying. Check the available space, app compatibility and the maintenance required for the tanks and brushes.
It depends on the controls available on the model. Check the manual to see whether you can schedule it locally without an internet connection. Ecovacs and Dreame describe features and set-up steps linked to their apps and Wi-Fi. Some set-ups also require Bluetooth or permission to access your phone’s location.
Plan to empty the dustbin and check the brushes and filter. If you have a robot mop, you’ll also need to look after the mop pads and water tank. Depending on the model, a docking station can take care of some tasks, but it won’t remove the need for all maintenance.
Don’t choose a robot mop assuming it will replace a deep clean. It may be suitable for light wet cleaning on hard floors, but you’ll need to check how well the model performs on the surfaces in your home. UFC-Que Choisir specifically recommends checking the cleaning performance of robot mops.
The index helps you compare how easy it is to repair the models covered. In France, the government departments responsible for the ecological transition list vacuum cleaners among these products. Check the index for the model you’re considering and make sure its maintenance parts are accessible.