For quick, frequent cleans, a cordless stick vacuum can be a good choice if its battery life in the mode you need is long enough to cover the areas you want to clean. For a larger home or thorough cleaning across several floor types, a cylinder vacuum is worth considering, although you’ll need to manage a power cable and a generally less manoeuvrable appliance. Having both makes sense if quick daily touch-ups and bigger cleans are separate needs. The guides from Que Choisir on stick and cylinder vacuums explain these differences in use.
If you regularly vacuum crumbs in the kitchen or dirt in the hallway, a stick vacuum that’s easy to take out and put away could suit your routine. Check how heavy it feels in your hand and how long the battery lasts in the mode you’ll use, rather than relying on the maximum runtime alone.
If a cleaning session covers several rooms, rugs or upholstered furniture, look at how well the vacuum performs on these surfaces, which tools are included, its capacity and its reach. Que Choisir’s guide recommends cylinder vacuums for larger areas, but it’s still important to compare individual models.
You could use a stick vacuum for frequent touch-ups and a cylinder vacuum for full cleans. This combination is only useful if one appliance can’t already handle your floors, upholstery and preferred cleaning time. You’ll also need space to store and maintain two appliances.
Consider it: for quick, frequent cleans when the battery life in your chosen mode is enough to cover the areas you have in mind.
Bear in mind: recharging and limited runtime can make longer cleaning sessions difficult, especially at high power.
Consider it: for larger areas and thorough cleans, when continuous use matters more than manoeuvrability.
Bear in mind: the cable, the need to change sockets and a generally less manoeuvrable appliance, as noted in Que Choisir’s guide to cylinder vacuums.
Consider them: if quick touch-ups and full cleans genuinely call for two different ways of cleaning.
Bear in mind: you’ll need space to store two appliances and maintain each one.
| Criteria | What to check | What I need |
|---|---|---|
| Cleaning time | For a stick vacuum, compare battery life in the mode you’ll use and with the floor head fitted, as well as charging time. For a cylinder vacuum, check its operating radius and where your sockets are. | I want to clean the areas I have in mind without having to stop to recharge or change sockets too often. |
| Floors and upholstery | Check which brushes and nozzles are included. Compare cleaning results on your floor types: Que Choisir tests vacuum cleaners on different types of flooring separately. | My rugs, wooden floors or sofa need the right attachments. A figure in watts or volts doesn’t tell me how well the appliance cleans each one. |
| Dust collection and maintenance | Check the capacity of the bag or dust container, how it empties, and how easy it is to access the filters and brush. If the model uses bags, check their reference and availability. | For a larger area or pet hair, I’d rather not have to empty it too often. I also consider how much contact with dust is involved during maintenance. |
| Manoeuvrability and storage | Check how heavy the appliance is to move, how comfortable it is to handle and how much space it takes up when stored. If you have two appliances, make room for each one. | If I often clean a few steps or small areas, taking the appliance out and putting it away should be easy in my home. |
| Repairability | In France, check the repairability index for the model in question and its detailed score, along with which parts are suitable for it. The French ministry responsible for ecological transition says vacuum cleaners are among the product categories covered by this index. | I want to identify the parts available and the repair terms for the specific appliance, rather than rely on a general promise from the brand. |
This figure may apply at low power and might not reflect how long it lasts when cleaning a rug. In its laboratory tests, Que Choisir found that the stick vacuums tested ran for an average of around ten minutes at maximum power. Your model’s runtime will depend on the mode you use.
Compare the stated runtimes for each mode and floor head, then check that they’ll cover the areas you want to clean in one go.
According to Que Choisir, the watts, volts or air watts used in product claims don’t tell you enough about cleaning performance on different floor types.
Look for results by floor type and make sure the vacuum comes with the brushes or nozzles you need for your rugs, hard floors and upholstery.
A bagged cylinder vacuum needs compatible bags. Filters and brushes also need the maintenance specified for the model.
Make a note of the reference for consumables and check they’re available, along with the instructions for replacing or cleaning them.
Replacing bags and maintaining filters are tasks you’ll need to factor in during use.
A parts catalogue or a brand’s commitment doesn’t confirm that the part you need will fit the model you’ve chosen.
Check the repairability index and its detailed score for the model in question, then confirm the part references and the terms of any commitment the brand has made.
These brands are included as a starting point for checking specific models. This doesn’t indicate their performance or mean they’re included in the product selection below.
Worth looking at if the availability of parts for the model you choose is important to your decision.
A brand to compare if you’re looking for a cordless stick vacuum and want to check the parts available for a specific model.
Worth considering when comparing bagged cylinder vacuums, particularly if accessories and spare parts are part of your decision.
This selection includes one bagged cylinder vacuum to consider for thorough cleans and four cordless stick vacuums for quick touch-ups. For each model, check the attachments, useful cleaning time and suitability for your floors.
Image unavailable
Worth considering if you’re looking for a bagged cylinder vacuum for full cleaning sessions. This model is listed as an EB61C2GRN with 550 W of power. Check that it has the brushes you need for your floors and find out which bags are compatible. As it has a power cable, you’ll need access to a socket while cleaning.
Image unavailable
Its cordless design is suited to quick touch-ups. The product title claims up to 65 minutes of runtime, a self-standing design and an LED touchscreen. Compare the runtime in the mode you’ll use and with the floor head you need, especially for rugs.
Image unavailable
Compare it for touch-ups on hard floors or rugs, depending on the attachments you need. The product title states up to 45 minutes of runtime and mentions an anti-tangle brush and touchscreen. Check the runtime in your chosen mode and how well it cleans your floors.
Image unavailable
This cordless stick vacuum could be a good option for quick cleans. The product title states that it has a removable battery and up to 60 minutes of runtime. Check how long it lasts with the floor head and mode you plan to use, and make sure it comes with the right attachments for your floors.
Image unavailable
Worth considering if you’d like an automatic dust-collection station for quick touch-ups. The product title claims up to 70 minutes of runtime and charging on the station. Check how long it lasts in your chosen mode, how much space the station needs and what maintenance it requires.
Check how long it lasts in the mode you’ll use and with the floor head fitted, to see whether it can clean the areas you have in mind in one session. Don’t rely on the maximum runtime alone. In its laboratory tests, Que Choisir found that the stick vacuums tested ran for an average of around ten minutes at maximum power. If your rugs need this mode, check the stated runtime for the model you’re considering.
Removing a bag may reduce contact with dust when emptying the vacuum, but you should still check the filtration and how to handle the model you choose. Also check the reference and availability of compatible bags.
You’ll need to empty the bag or dust container and maintain the filters and brushes according to the model’s instructions. Before choosing, check how easy these parts are to access and identify compatible consumables.
Check the repairability index for the model in question and the details behind its score, then identify which parts are suitable for it. The French ministry responsible for ecological transition says vacuum cleaners are among the categories covered. A general claim about parts availability doesn’t replace checking the specific model.