In a small home, a stick vacuum is handy for frequent quick cleans and easy to store. But it can replace a cylinder vacuum only if it cleans your floors effectively and has enough battery life on the setting you use to tackle a full clean too. If you have demanding carpets or regularly clean thoroughly, keeping a compact cylinder vacuum as well is worth considering. A robot can automate some cleaning, but you’ll still need to check how well it works on your floors and keep it maintained.
If you often vacuum a few areas and put the appliance away straight afterwards, a stick vacuum is worth considering. Que Choisir highlights how easy it is to store in a small home. However, check how long it lasts on the setting you’ll actually use, rather than relying on the maximum battery life quoted.
Don’t let easy storage distract you from the floors you need to clean. Compare vacuuming performance on your floor coverings and check which cleaning head is included. As Que Choisir points out for cylinder vacuums, motor power alone isn’t enough to judge how well an appliance cleans.
If you plan to keep your vacuum for a long time, check its repairability index and look for parts that match its exact model number. A battery or brush listed for a different variant may not be suitable for your appliance.
First decide whether you need an appliance for quick cleans, a full clean or both. Each of the four options is suited to different needs.
Worth considering: if you want to grab the vacuum for a quick clean, especially on hard floors, then put it away without dealing with a cable.
The trade-off: before making it your only vacuum, check how well it cleans your floors and how long it lasts at the power setting you need.
Worth considering: if thorough cleaning, carpets or difficult surfaces are a regular part of your routine.
The trade-off: you’ll need space for the appliance and its cable. If you choose a model with a bag, you’ll also need to replace the bags.
Worth considering: if you want to automate regular cleans and your home’s layout allows the robot to move around freely.
The trade-off: Que Choisir notes that cleaning results aren’t always convincing. The dust container and other parts of the robot also need looking after.
Worth considering: if you like having a stick vacuum to hand for everyday cleaning, but also need to clean carpets regularly or give your home a more thorough clean.
The trade-off: two appliances take up more space and both need maintaining.
| Factor | What to check | Think about your needs |
|---|---|---|
| Stick vacuum battery life | Compare battery life across settings and with the brush you’ll use. In Que Choisir tests, stick vacuums last around ten minutes on average at maximum power. This result doesn’t apply to every model. | I want to finish the clean I’ve planned, including areas that need a higher power setting. |
| Cleaning performance on different floors | Look for tests on the floor coverings you have, then check which cleaning head comes with the variant you’ve chosen. For cylinder vacuums, Que Choisir points out that motor power alone doesn’t determine how well they clean. | I need to be able to clean my rugs, carpets or the grooves in my wooden floors during a full clean, not just a quick once-over. |
| Storage space and manoeuvrability | Measure the space available for storage, including any stand or docking base. Check the weight in the configuration you’ll use and, for a robot, whether it can move around your furniture. | In a small home, I need an appliance that’s easy to reach without its storage getting in the way. |
| Maintenance and spare parts | Check how easy it is to access the dust container, filter and brush. In France, the repairability index is a score out of 10 displayed by the ministries responsible for the ecological transition. Also check which parts are available for the exact model number. | I’d like to know how to maintain the appliance and where to find a compatible battery or accessories if I need them. |
| Using a robot vacuum | Look for tests on the floors in your home and how well the robot navigates around obstacles. Make room for the docking base and consider how you’ll empty the dust container and maintain the appliance. | I’m interested in automating regular cleans, but I still need to be able to tackle areas where the robot doesn’t get the results I want. |
The quoted battery life may refer to the least powerful setting. In its tests, Que Choisir measures an average of around ten minutes at maximum power for stick vacuums.
Compare battery life on the setting and with the accessory you plan to use, especially if your carpets or certain areas need more power.
For cylinder vacuums, Que Choisir highlights the importance of useful suction power and the design of the cleaning head. The motor’s power rating alone doesn’t tell you how well the appliance will clean your floors.
Look for tests on the types of flooring you have and check which brush comes with the model you’re buying.
Battery and accessory catalogues are organised by model number. A part listed for one range isn’t necessarily compatible with every appliance.
Make a note of the full model code and check the matching battery, charger, filters and brush. Also compare the repairability index shown.
A robot vacuum needs looking after and its dust container must be emptied. An auto-empty station also takes up space, so you’ll need to allow for it.
Measure the space for the docking base and check how to access the dust container and parts that need cleaning before choosing this option.
These brand examples can help you check a specific model and its parts; they don’t represent every product in each brand’s range.
Rowenta’s product page for the X-Pert 7.60 cordless stick vacuum includes a repairability index for this model.
Bosch has a catalogue of spare parts and accessories for vacuum cleaners, which you can search using the appliance’s model number.
Dyson France lists batteries, chargers and replacement docking stations for its vacuum cleaners.
This selection includes cordless stick vacuums for everyday cleaning, plus a bagged cylinder vacuum to consider if you’d like to keep a corded appliance for full cleans. The quoted specifications don’t replace testing a vacuum on the floors in your home.
Image unavailable
Worth considering for frequent quick cleans if a stick vacuum suits your storage space. The quoted battery life is up to 50 minutes. Before relying on it as your only vacuum, check how long it lasts on your floors with the brush and setting you need.
Image unavailable
A corded option to consider for full cleans if you have room to store a cylinder vacuum and its cable. The stated motor power is 550 W. Also compare how well the cleaning head performs on your floors and check which bags are compatible.
Image unavailable
This stick vacuum with a removable battery is worth considering for everyday cleaning. Its title lists 45 000 Pa and up to 60 minutes of battery life. These figures alone don’t show how well it cleans carpets or how long it will last with the brush and setting you’ll use.
Image unavailable
The freestanding design is worth considering if you want to keep your stick vacuum within easy reach between cleans. The title lists up to 65 minutes of battery life and 60 000 Pa. Check that you have room to store it, and look for cleaning results on your floors rather than assuming its effectiveness from the pascal figure.
Image unavailable
The two speed settings and removable battery are worth considering if you need different levels of cleaning power. The title lists 45 kPa, but that doesn’t tell you how well it will clean your floors. Also compare battery life at the setting you need and check how much storage space is available.
Yes, if it cleans your floors effectively and has enough battery life on the setting you actually use for a full clean. However, Que Choisir presents stick vacuums mainly as secondary appliances. If you have demanding carpets or regularly need to clean thoroughly, compare one with a compact cylinder vacuum before deciding to do without the latter.
The figures aren’t useful to compare unless you know which power setting and accessory were used. In its tests, Que Choisir finds that stick vacuums last around ten minutes on average at maximum power. As an example of a manufacturer’s claim, Electrolux states that its 900 EP91UB21WB runs for 80 minutes in normal mode and 17 minutes in boost mode, both with a motorised accessory. These figures aren’t independent test results.
Check the repairability index shown for the model you’ve chosen. The ministries responsible for the ecological transition describe it as a score out of 10 that tells you how repairable a product is. Then check with the manufacturer which parts fit your exact model, particularly the battery, charger, filters and brush.
Not necessarily. A robot can automate regular cleans, but Que Choisir notes that its results aren’t always convincing. Look for tests on your floors and check how it navigates around furniture. You’ll also need to empty the dust container and maintain the robot, so keep another option for areas it doesn’t clean well enough.