If you regularly make espresso without capsules, a portafilter machine is a good choice if you’re happy to measure out the coffee and clean the parts after use. A bean-to-cup machine is better if you’d rather use whole beans with less effort for each cup. According to Que Choisir, however, bean-to-cup machines take up more space and are noisier than capsule systems. Their containers and brewing unit also need regular cleaning. If the convenience of individual portions matters most, capsules or soft coffee pads are still an option, provided you check which format the machine accepts and how it needs descaling.
The right choice mainly depends on how often you make coffee and how much effort you’re happy to put in each day.
If you want to choose your own beans and make drinks with minimal effort for each cup, consider a bean-to-cup machine. Make sure you have enough space, and check the manual for instructions on cleaning the containers and brewing unit. Que Choisir notes that the containers and brewing chamber need regular rinsing.
Soft coffee pads and capsules save you from measuring out coffee for every drink. If you’d like to cut down on capsules without switching to a portafilter machine, compare the pad formats accepted, the steps involved in making a drink and the descaling process for the model you’re considering.
A portafilter machine is a good fit if you want to choose your coffee and control how much you use, fit the filter and clean the machine. It involves more hands-on preparation than making a drink at the touch of a button. Also check whether you’ll need a separate grinder to use whole beans.
Start with the coffee you want to use, then consider how each system fits your available space and the maintenance you can realistically keep up with.
| Criteria | What to check | To suit your needs |
|---|---|---|
| Coffee format | Check which capsules or pads are compatible with the exact model. If you want to use ground coffee or whole beans, check whether you need a portafilter, a separate grinder or a machine with a built-in grinder. | I want to choose my own beans: a bean-to-cup machine, or a portafilter machine paired with a grinder, is worth considering. If I’d rather use pre-measured portions, I’ll check the format first. |
| Everyday steps | Compare the effort involved in measuring out coffee and cleaning up after each drink. A portafilter machine requires manual preparation; an automatic machine reduces the steps involved, but still needs maintenance. | I enjoy making my coffee: a portafilter machine could suit me. If I mainly want to cut down on the steps for each cup, I’ll look at the controls on automatic or portion-based models. |
| Maintenance | Check the manual for descaling instructions, how to rinse the containers and how to access the brewing unit. If you make milk-based drinks, also check how to clean the steam wand or milk system. | I’ll choose a machine with maintenance tasks I can keep up with regularly. De’Longhi France explains that how often its bean-to-cup machines need descaling depends, among other things, on water hardness. |
| Space and noise | Measure the space available, including room to fill the water tanks or remove the containers. Que Choisir notes that a bean-to-cup machine takes up more space and is noisier than a capsule system. | My worktop space is limited, or noise matters in my household: I’ll check the dimensions and operating conditions of the exact model before choosing a bean-to-cup machine. |
| Portions and recycling | Find out what the capsules or pads are made from and check the local collection guidance. ADEME recommends avoiding individually wrapped packaging or single portions where possible. | If I want to reduce individually wrapped portions, I’ll consider ground coffee or whole beans. If I keep using capsules, I’ll check the local recycling options rather than assume they can be recycled. |
The format you choose determines which coffee you can use and which cleaning products you’ll need. Switching to beans, ground coffee or pads doesn’t mean you can skip descaling.
Before choosing, check the coffee format the exact model accepts, along with any filters, cleaning products or accessories listed in its manual.
According to Que Choisir, the coffee-ground and drip trays on a bean-to-cup machine need regular rinsing, as does its brewing chamber, though less often. One-touch controls don’t mean you can skip these tasks.
Before choosing a model, check how easy it is to access the parts that need cleaning, what alerts the machine provides and what’s involved in descaling.
Allow time to rinse the parts and descale the machine.
The material the capsule is made from and the collection scheme actually available both matter. ADEME recommends avoiding individually wrapped portions where possible.
If you keep using capsules, check the local guidance for their material. If you want to reduce individual portions, also consider ground coffee and whole beans.
Nespresso France says its repair service may not be available if the necessary parts are out of stock. So, an advertised repair option doesn’t guarantee that every machine can be repaired.
For the model you’re interested in, check the information on spare parts, accessories and the terms of the repair service.
This overview covers the ranges and documents mentioned, not every machine from each brand. Check the manuals for the specific models you’re interested in before making your choice.
De’Longhi France’s support documents explain how to maintain its bean-to-cup machines, including the Magnifica Evo Next.
Sage’s Barista Express is aimed at people who want to get hands-on with making their espresso.
Nespresso is a good option for households that want to keep using pre-measured coffee capsules.
The SENSEO range offers soft coffee pads and individually portioned drinks.
These models showcase three ways to make coffee at home: a bean-to-cup machine for whole beans, a portafilter machine for making coffee by hand, and a multi-format capsule machine for individual portions.
Image unavailable
This machine with a built-in grinder is a good way for a household to enjoy whole-bean coffee and make drinks at home regularly. Check the manual for rinsing and descaling instructions specific to the EP2230/10, and make sure you have enough space for the machine and its containers.
Image unavailable
This automatic Magnifica Evo is for households considering whole-bean coffee and a LatteCrema model. If milk-based drinks are important to you, check the ECAM290.61.B manual for instructions on cleaning the milk system, then measure the space available on your worktop.
Image unavailable
This bean-to-cup machine is another option if you want to replace capsules with automatic coffee preparation. To compare the ECAM220.21.WW with other Magnifica models, check the drinks it makes, how much space it takes up and which parts need cleaning, as listed in its manual.
Image unavailable
A portafilter machine is a hands-on option if you’d rather use ground coffee than capsules. With the EC685.BK, allow time for preparation and cleaning after use. If you’re starting with whole beans, check which grinder you’ll need.
Image unavailable
The H2B is still a multi-format capsule machine. It’s best suited to people who want to keep using capsules while also considering the ESE pad and ground coffee formats mentioned in its name. Before relying on either of these options, check which adaptors are included with the version on sale and whether your cups are compatible.
No. Nespresso France recommends descaling its machines every three months or after around 300 capsules. Follow the instructions for your model and the precautions for using the descaling product.
Rinse the parts listed in the manual and run descaling cycles. Que Choisir specifically mentions the coffee-ground and drip trays, as well as the brewing chamber, which needs rinsing less often. De’Longhi France explains that descaling frequency depends, among other things, on water hardness. Check the instructions for your model, including how to clean the milk system if it has one.
No. Instructions depend on the material and the collection options available locally. ADEME distinguishes, among other things, between paper capsules and capsules that can be returned through a dedicated collection scheme. Check the guidance for your capsules before throwing them away.
Look for information about spare parts and repair services for the exact model. Nespresso France says repairs may not be available if the necessary parts are out of stock. So, general information about a repair service doesn’t confirm what will be possible for your machine.