For regular, deep cleaning of rugs and carpets, a cylinder vacuum cleaner is generally the best place to start, according to Que Choisir. However, compare the specific model’s performance on dust and embedded fibres. A bagged model means less contact with dust when you empty it; a stick vacuum can serve as your main cleaner if its performance on textiles and its battery life in the mode you use are sufficient for your home.
If pet hair gets trapped in the fibres, look separately at performance on dust and embedded fibres. Que Choisir’s testing assesses both; having a brush designed for textiles does not, on its own, prove how well the vacuum performs.
If you need to clean several rooms and textile flooring, a cylinder vacuum is worth comparing carefully: Que Choisir describes it as suitable for larger areas. If you prefer a stick vacuum, check that it can last for a full cleaning session in the mode you need.
Removing a full bag exposes you to less dust than cleaning a bin, according to Que Choisir. Whether you choose a bagged or bagless model, also check how easy it is to access the filters and remove hair or fur tangled around the brush.
First choose a type of vacuum that suits the size of your home, then compare how the specific model performs on your floors and what maintenance it requires.
Consider it: for a thorough clean across several rooms if you’d rather remove a full bag than empty a bin.
The trade-off: it needs to be plugged in, and you’ll have to replace its compatible bags.
Consider it: if you want a cylinder vacuum without disposable bags and don’t mind emptying its bin.
The trade-off: cleaning the bin exposes you to more dust than removing a bag, according to Que Choisir.
Consider it: for shorter cleaning sessions, or as your main vacuum if its battery life in the mode you use and its performance on rugs and fibres suit your home.
The trade-off: Que Choisir notes that the advertised maximum battery life does not necessarily reflect how long it will last at higher power.
| What to consider | What to check | What I need |
|---|---|---|
| Cleaning textiles | Compare test results for dust in rugs and embedded fibres. Check which floorhead comes with the model; don’t assume it will perform well based on the stated power alone. | Pet hair gets trapped in my rugs: I want to know whether the vacuum picks it up, not just whether it removes visible dust. Que Choisir tests each of these types of dirt separately in its cylinder and stick vacuum tests. |
| Emptying and filtration | Choose between removing a bag and emptying a bin. Check how to maintain the filter and which replacement parts are compatible. | I’d like to minimise contact with dust: according to Que Choisir, removing a full bag exposes you to less dust than cleaning a bagless vacuum’s bin. |
| Stick vacuum battery life | Compare the battery life in the mode you’ll need for rugs, not just the advertised maximum. Also check whether the bin is large enough for a full cleaning session. | I want to clean several rooms without recharging or emptying the bin too often. If a stick vacuum is going to be my only vacuum, its actual running time matters. |
| Brushes and accessories | Check which brush is included, how easy it is to remove tangled hair, and whether any additional accessories will physically fit. | Hair also builds up on my sofa or stairs: I’m interested in a suitable upholstery brush, as long as it fits my vacuum. |
| Regular maintenance | Find out which bags or filters fit the model and how to remove the brush. If you’re considering a stick vacuum, also check the information about its battery. | I’m looking for a maintenance routine I can keep up with, especially if hair and fur regularly get tangled around the roller. |
A brush advertised for pet hair doesn’t prove that the vacuum will work well on your rug. Que Choisir’s tests distinguish between dust pick-up and embedded fibres.
For every model you’re considering, look for results on both types of dirt and check which brush is actually included.
According to Que Choisir, a stick vacuum’s maximum battery life is measured at the lowest power setting. It may not reflect how long it will last when cleaning rugs on a higher setting.
Compare the battery life in the mode you’ll use, then check whether the bin can hold enough to finish the job without an inconvenient pause.
A bag needs replacing, a bin needs emptying and hair tangled around a brush needs removing. These tasks are particularly important in a home with pets.
Before choosing, find out which consumables are compatible and check how to access the brush and filters.
An accessory designed for textiles may not fit your vacuum’s tube. For example, Rowenta specifies diameter requirements and locking-system exceptions for its ZR900601 mini turbo brush.
Check the accessory’s compatibility list, as well as the diameter and attachment system of your vacuum.
These models give you examples of different configurations to compare. Their advertised features are no substitute for test results on rugs and fibres for the specific model you choose.
The ProAnimal range includes both bagged and bagless cylinder vacuums. Product information from Bosch Electroménager France describes their features, but does not provide a comparison of their performance on rugs.
Miele France presents the Guard M1 Cat & Dog as a bagged cylinder vacuum for looking after rugs and carpets in homes with pets.
Rowenta’s ZR900601 mini turbo brush is an accessory to consider for a compatible vacuum. It does not indicate how all the brand’s vacuum cleaners perform.
These Joybuy models include bagged and bagless cylinder vacuums, as well as stick vacuums for homes with rugs or pets. To choose a main vacuum, compare the specific model’s performance on rugs and fibres, then consider how it needs to be emptied and its battery life.
Image unavailable
A bagless cylinder vacuum to consider if you don’t mind emptying a bin when cleaning your rugs regularly. The model name indicates 900 W; above all, compare test results for dust and embedded fibres, and check which brush is included.
Image unavailable
A bagged cylinder vacuum to consider for a thorough clean if you’d rather remove a full bag than empty a bin. Check how this model performs on rugs and fibres, which brush is included and which replacement bags are compatible.
Image unavailable
The advertised pet brush makes this stick vacuum worth considering for pet hair on textiles; its name indicates suction power of 55 kPa. If you’re thinking of making it your main vacuum, check how it performs on rugs and fibres, and how long it lasts in the mode you use.
Image unavailable
This stick vacuum is listed with an anti-tangle brush, an emptying station and suction power of 27 kPa. If you’re cleaning rugs for a long session, check its performance on fibres, its battery life in the mode you need and which bags fit the station.
Image unavailable
This stick vacuum is designed for homes with pets. Before choosing it for rugs and carpets, compare its performance on embedded fibres and check whether its battery life in the mode you need and how often it needs emptying suit your home.
Look at the test for fibres on rugs as well as the one for dust. Que Choisir’s tests for cylinder and stick vacuums each use 1 g of fibres similar to pet hair; the stick vacuum test also records how many passes are needed.
No. A power rating alone doesn’t tell you how well a vacuum will pick up dirt from fibres. Compare results on rugs and embedded fibres, then check which floorhead comes with the model you’re considering. Que Choisir assesses these as separate criteria in its tests.
It can do the job if the specific model cleans your rugs and their fibres well enough and lasts for a full session in the mode you need. Que Choisir generally describes stick vacuums as supplementary cleaners and points out that their advertised maximum battery life is measured at the lowest power setting.
Yes. According to Que Choisir, removing a full bag exposes you to less dust than cleaning the bin of a bagless vacuum. Also check which bags are compatible and what maintenance the model needs; this doesn’t indicate how well it will clean your rugs.