Joybuy Insights

Earth Rated dog toys: which model should you choose based on size and type of play?

An Earth Rated dog toy can be used for tugging, fetching, mental stimulation or chewing. But a well-written product page doesn't guarantee the model will suit your companion. A toy that's too small can be difficult to grip, while one chosen for its looks alone might end up at the back of a cupboard.

Before you place your order, keep three common pitfalls in mind:

  • Don't confuse durability with an indestructible toy: no toy can withstand heavy chewing indefinitely. Its lifespan depends on your dog's jaw strength, how often it's used, and the way your dog plays.
  • Don't overlook the dimensions: a size that works for a small dog won't necessarily suit a large one, even if the shape looks the same.
  • Don't choose an outdoor toy without checking how to clean it: a model that floats, is easy to spot in the grass, and can go in the dishwasher will often be more practical day-to-day than one that's fiddly to clean.

What to check before you buy

1. Material and chewing level

Several Earth Rated toys, including the TUG, FETCH, TREAT and CHEW models, are made from natural rubber. This material offers a soft grip and some flexibility, but it doesn't make the toy indestructible. If your dog is a heavy chewer, check regularly for cracks, loose pieces or areas that have become very thin.

The Flyer is made from thermoplastic elastomer, or TPE. This material is described as gentle on your dog's mouth and pleasant to handle, but the manufacturer states that the frisbee is not designed to be chewed. So keep it for fetch games and put it away once playtime is over.

2. Choosing the right size for your dog's mouth

The dimensions listed on the product page are a valuable guide:

  • 8.5 × 5.5 × 8.5 cm: the compact FETCH size, suitable if your dog can pick it up easily without any risk of swallowing it or getting it stuck in their mouth.
  • 10 × 6.5 × 10 cm: the large FETCH size, designed for dogs that need a bigger grip.
  • 13 × 8.5 cm or 11 × 7 cm: the TREAT sizes, to be filled with kibble, treats or a paste suitable for your pet's diet.
  • 21.5 cm diameter: the large Flyer, intended for large adult dogs.
  • 28 × 14 × 14 cm or 35.5 × 17.5 × 17.5 cm: the TUG models with handles, to be chosen according to your dog's build and the range of movement you want during play.

Labels like "for small dogs" or "for large dogs" are a guide, not a substitute for checking the measurements. Also consider whether your dog can carry the toy and release it easily.

3. Intended use and ease of cleaning

An occupational dog toy should be fillable and used in a calm environment. The TREAT and Enrichment Toy models are particularly well suited to dogs that enjoy foraging for their food. A tug toy for dogs like the TUG is best used for interactive play with you.

For outings, a floating toy is ideal by a lake, at the beach or in a suitable outdoor space. The FETCH and Flyer models are designed to float, while their yellow colour makes them easier to spot in the grass. As for models described as dishwasher safe, they should be placed on the top rack, following the manufacturer's instructions.

Which option suits your profile?

Recommended for: beginners and smaller budgets
Earth Rated Fetch 8.5x5.5x8.5CM

Earth Rated Fetch 8.5x5.5x8.5CM

Why this model suits this profile: This compact size is a great way to start with a fetch ball for your dog, whether on dry land or in the water.

How this model avoids the pitfall

Its dimensions are clearly stated, and its yellow colour reduces the risk of losing sight of it in the grass.

Its main advantage

Natural rubber from responsible sources, an unpredictable bounce, it floats, and it can be cleaned on the top rack of the dishwasher.

Recommended for: fans of premium products
EARTH RATED Enrichment Toy for Adult Dogs and Puppies Green - Size S

EARTH RATED Enrichment Toy for Adult Dogs and Puppies Green - Size S

Why this model suits this profile: This toy for puppies or small dogs combines food foraging, an ergonomic grip, and the option to freeze it for variety during play sessions.

How this model avoids the pitfall

The size S at 17.8 × 5.1 cm stops you from choosing an occupational toy that's too big for a small dog.

Its main advantage

Natural rubber, grooves, can be filled with dry or wet food, freezer-safe and dishwasher-safe on the top rack.

Recommended for: specific uses and heavy users
Earth Rated TUG Rubber 35.5x17.5x1 Piece

Earth Rated TUG Rubber 35.5x17.5x1 Piece

Why this model suits this profile: This tug toy for dogs is designed for interactive sessions, with two handles and a more comfortable grip distance.

How this model avoids the pitfall

Its large size and handles reduce the risk of gripping the toy too close to your dog's mouth.

Its main advantage

Natural rubber, a curved shape, two ergonomic handles, and can be cleaned on the top rack of the dishwasher.

Recommended for: outdoor activities and water play
Earth Rated FLYER 21.5x4x21.5cm - 1 Piece

Earth Rated FLYER 21.5x4x21.5cm - 1 Piece

Why this model suits this profile: With its 21.5 cm diameter, this frisbee is designed for large adult dogs that love to run, fetch and play near water.

How this model avoids the pitfall

The size, rolled edge and hollow centre are all detailed, making it easier to check that your dog will be able to grip it properly.

Its main advantage

TPE, it floats, a highly visible yellow colour for outdoors, and dishwasher safe according to the product instructions.

Looking for other options?

We've put together a comprehensive selection, updated in real time, of products that meet these criteria as well as European safety requirements.

Frequently asked questions about Earth Rated dog toys

Is an Earth Rated toy suitable for a puppy?

Some models are suitable for puppies, particularly the Enrichment Toy in size S. However, choose a size that's compatible with your pet's mouth, supervise every session, and remove the toy as soon as it shows signs of wear.

How long can you use a chew toy?

There's no one-size-fits-all answer. Inspect the toy before and after each use. Cracks, missing pieces or significant wear mean it should be replaced, even if it still looks usable.

Can these toys be used with frozen treats?

The TREAT and Enrichment Toy models are described as freezer-safe. Only use food that's suitable for your dog, take their dietary habits into account, and always supervise them when they're playing with the toy.