Homes with a mix of floor types
If you switch between hard floors and rugs in several rooms, compare the brushes supplied and the results stated for each surface. UFC-Que Choisir notes that performance varies by model and floor type.
Who is this option for?
People keen to limit dust when emptying
If you want to limit contact with dust when disposing of dirt, compare removing a sealed bag with emptying a bin. UFC-Que Choisir notes that emptying a bagless model’s bin can expose you to dust.
Homes where you also vacuum upholstery
If you plan to clean sofas, corners or bedding, check which nozzles and brushes are included with the exact model. Their presence alone doesn’t prove they’ll work effectively on every fabric.
What to compare
Bagged cylinder vacuum
Choose this if: you want to limit contact with dust when emptying it.
Bear in mind: bags and filters must be compatible with the model and replaced depending on how you use it.
Bagless cylinder vacuum
Choose this if: you’d rather avoid buying bags regularly and don’t mind emptying the bin.
Bear in mind: the bin and filters need regular handling and maintenance.
For a thorough clean, versatility depends on the floorhead and accessories actually included. UFC-Que Choisir recommends comparing performance across different surfaces rather than relying on a single power figure.
| What matters to you | What to check before buying | Who might this suit? |
|---|---|---|
| Hard floors and rugs | Check test results for each floor type and see which floorhead and settings are included. | I need to vacuum wooden floors and rugs in several rooms: consumers who put this versatility first are estimated to account for around 33% of top priorities. |
| Dust when emptying | Compare how the bag is removed with the procedure for emptying the bin, and check which filter is compatible. | I’d rather limit contact with dust when disposing of dirt: consumers who prioritise this are estimated to account for around 27% of main concerns. |
| Furniture, corners and bedding | Check for nozzles for upholstery and narrow spaces, and make sure they’re included in the box. | I also want to clean furniture and corners: consumers who prioritise these surfaces are estimated to account for nearly 20% of main concerns. |
| Moving it around and maintenance | Compare the weight, operating radius and references for bags, filters and parts. | I need to move the appliance between several rooms and plan for its maintenance: consumers who prioritise manoeuvrability and consumables are estimated to account for around 20% of main concerns. |
Pitfalls to avoid
-
Assuming motor power tells you how well it cleans
Suction performance also depends on the floorhead and type of floor. The power rating alone won’t tell you how well the appliance will clean a rug or hard floor.
Compare results by surface and check the floorhead supplied, rather than relying on the wattage alone.
-
Thinking a bagless model needs no maintenance
Going without bags means one less recurring purchase, but you’ll still need to empty the bin and maintain or replace the filters, depending on the model.
Before choosing, find out which filters and parts are compatible with the appliance.
Also allow time to empty and clean the bin and maintain the filters.
-
Assuming every version in a range comes with the same accessories
Accessory lists vary by model, and an included brush doesn’t prove it will work effectively on every fabric.
Check the full model reference and what’s included in the box, particularly for furniture and bedding.
If the accessory you need isn’t included, check that it’s compatible before considering a separate purchase.
Brands to know
Rowenta
The bagged RO6179EA and bagless RO7C36EA give you two different configurations to compare.
- For the RO6179EA, Rowenta lists a 4.5 L Hygiene+ bag, a parquet brush and a mini turbo brush. For the RO7C36EA, the brand lists a 2.5 L bin and a parquet brush.
- The stated operating radius differs between these models: 12 m for the RO6179EA and 9 m for the RO7C36EA. These are manufacturer specifications, not comparative test results.
Bosch
The bagged ProAnimal BGB41PET1 and bagless BGS41PET1 come with different features, so check which suits the cleaning you have in mind.
- Bosch states that the BGS41PET1 comes with a turbo brush, a hard-floor brush and a mini turbo brush. The BGB41PET1 has a 4.0 L bag and integrated nozzles for crevices and upholstery.
- The accessories and capacities of one model don’t apply to the other. The manufacturer’s specifications don’t demonstrate comparative effectiveness on furniture or bedding.
Electrolux
The Pure D8 PD82-4ST is a bagged model worth considering if you’re comparing operating radius and the brushes supplied.
- Electrolux states that this model has a 12 m operating radius, a 3.5 L bag and a parquet brush.
- Check the accessory list and filter type for the exact model before buying. Electrolux asks for the PNC number to identify compatible parts.
Miele
The Complete C2, Complete C3 and Classic C1 ranges show why it’s important to check that consumables are compatible with your model.
- Miele states that GN HyClean Pure bags are suitable for these ranges, among others. The pack shown contains four bags and two filters.
- This compatibility may not extend to every version. Check the exact appliance and filter references.
Cylinder vacuum cleaners to explore
This selection includes bagged and bagless cylinder vacuum cleaners, with features listed for floors, rugs and some types of furniture or hard-to-reach areas.
No image available
Hoover H-ENERGY 300 HE330ALG 011 bagged vacuum cleaner
Worth considering if you’re looking for a bagged cylinder vacuum with accessories listed for floors, rugs and furniture.
Stated power: 850 W; bag: 4 L; stated operating radius: 9.5 m.
The product listing specifies a brush for hard floors and rugs, a mini turbo brush and a 2-in-1 accessory for furniture and crevices.
No image available
Electrolux 600 EB61C4OG bagged vacuum cleaner
Worth considering if you’re looking for a bagged cylinder vacuum with a stated operating radius of 12 m to cover several rooms.
Bag: 3.5 L; washable filter listed.
The product listing mentions an all-floor brush, a parquet brush and a turbo brush.
No image available
Electrolux EB61C2GRN bagged vacuum cleaner
Worth considering if you’d like to compare another bagged model with brushes listed for different floor types.
Stated power: 550 W; bag: 3.5 L; stated operating radius: 12 m.
The product listing mentions an all-floor brush, a parquet brush and a turbo brush.
No image available
Philips FC9556/09 5000 Series bagless vacuum cleaner
Worth considering if you prefer a bagless cylinder vacuum with accessories listed for floors, rugs and furniture.
Stated power: 900 W; bin: 1.5 L; stated operating radius: 9 m.
The product listing mentions a TriActive+ all-floor brush, a turbo brush for rugs and an accessory for furniture.
No image available
H.Koenig STC48 bagless cyclonic vacuum cleaner
Worth considering if you’re looking for a bagless cylinder vacuum with a removable bin and a nozzle for narrow spaces.
Bin: 2 L; washable HEPA 12 filter listed.
The product listing describes use on different floor types and a 2-in-1 crevice nozzle.
Frequently asked questions
Does higher electrical power guarantee better rug cleaning?
No. UFC-Que Choisir recommends looking at the floorhead design and suction results for different surfaces, rather than judging performance by the motor’s wattage alone.
Will a brush listed for furniture clean bedding just as well?
Not necessarily. Check which accessory comes with the appliance and the uses listed for the exact model. The presence of a brush doesn’t prove it will work effectively on every fabric.
How can I plan for bags, filters and replacement parts?
Make a note of the appliance’s full reference, then check which consumables and parts are compatible with the manufacturer. For the PD82-4ST, Electrolux asks for the PNC number to identify parts. Requirements vary by model and how you use it.
What should you do with your old vacuum cleaner in France?
The French Ministry for Ecological Transition says an electrical appliance can be taken to a collection point or household waste recycling centre, returned to a retailer, or passed on to a social and solidarity economy organisation.