Which criteria should you consider first?
For a kitchen without a direct outlet, first establish whether a separate duct to the outside can be installed. Recirculation and extraction then involve different installation and maintenance requirements; in either case, you’ll also need to consider your existing ventilation.
Recirculating cooker hood
Consider this: when an external outlet isn’t practical and the hood can be fitted with the accessories required for recirculation.
Bear in mind: filtered air is returned to the kitchen, and odour filters need maintenance specific to their product reference.
External extraction cooker hood
Consider this: if a dedicated duct can vent outdoors and its route complies with the instructions and building requirements.
Bear in mind: the duct length, bends and any requirements relating to the work could affect your plans.
| Criterion |
What to check |
Consumers concerned |
| Duct and building |
Check the route, diameter and bends against the hood’s instructions; find out what requirements apply to the external outlet. |
If a duct is part of my kitchen plans, I want to know whether it can genuinely vent outdoors before choosing an installation method. Around 42% of consumers put this feasibility check first. |
| Cooking without an external outlet |
Confirm that the hood supports recirculation and has a compatible kit and filters; take the type of hob into account. |
Without a practical outlet, I’m looking for a hood that works in this set-up, without assuming that it vents air outdoors. This is the top priority for around 33% of consumers. |
| Filter maintenance |
Identify the odour-filter reference and check its replacement or regeneration instructions. |
If I choose recirculation, I want to be able to maintain the filters suited to my hood over time. Around 25% of consumers make compatibility and maintenance their top priority. |
The type of hob can affect your decision: Qualitel advises against recirculation with gas cooking, as this mode does not vent combustion pollutants outdoors. A recirculating hood also doesn’t remove the need to maintain your home’s ventilation. ADEME and Qualitel distinguish the hood’s local function from the air renewal provided by ventilation.
Cooker hoods for a recirculation project
These hoods are featured for kitchens where recirculation is being considered; their descriptions also state that they offer extraction. Before choosing either mode, check the recirculation accessories for the exact model or confirm that an external duct is feasible. If you have a gas hob, bear in mind Qualitel’s caution about recirculation.
Image unavailable
Heinrich's HDU 7631 IX, 60 cm wall-mounted cooker hood
Worth considering for a kitchen without an external outlet: the listed modes include both recirculation and extraction.
The product name states that a charcoal filter is included and that it has touch controls. Check the instructions for maintenance details for the filter supplied with this model.
View on Joybuy
Image unavailable
Heinrich's HDU 7622 SW, 60 cm wall-mounted cooker hood
Consider this angled hood if you want to compare recirculation and extraction for a 60 cm wall-mounted space.
The product name states an airflow rate of 300 m³/h and that a charcoal filter is included. Check the maintenance instructions for the filter that’s compatible with this model.
View on Joybuy
Image unavailable
Ciarra CBCS6765B, 60 cm angled cooker hood
Worth considering for a wall-mounted installation where recirculation is an option, provided you confirm which filters are suitable.
The product name states 580 m³/h, three speeds and touch controls. These specifications don’t replace the need to check the installation and filter maintenance requirements.
View on Joybuy
Image unavailable
Comfee TSHM77SS-60, 60 cm T-shaped cooker hood
This wall-mounted hood is listed as offering both recirculation and extraction. For a kitchen without an outlet, check what accessories are needed for recirculation.
The product name states 650 m³/h and gesture and touch controls. Check the reference for the compatible charcoal filter or kit before choosing recirculation.
View on Joybuy
Image unavailable
Comfee' CH90J64ET4A2B2-EU, 90 cm angled cooker hood
Worth considering if a 90 cm angled hood suits your space and you’re thinking about recirculation.
The product name states 620 m³/h and four speeds. For recirculation, check which kit and charcoal filter are compatible, along with their maintenance instructions.
View on Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can you connect an extraction hood to mechanical ventilation?
Bosch advises against connecting an extraction hood’s duct to mechanical ventilation: it should vent outdoors through a separate duct. As Qualitel explains, mechanical ventilation has a separate role in renewing the air in your home.
Does a recirculating cooker hood replace kitchen ventilation?
No. It filters the air and returns it to the room, while your home’s ventilation system renews the air. Keep your existing ventilation system in place and maintain it separately from the cooker hood.
What should you check before creating an external outlet?
Check the duct route and any applicable requirements before starting work. The rules published by Légifrance distinguish, among other things, between work that changes a building’s external appearance and, in a block of flats, work affecting communal areas or the external appearance. Ask your local planning department and, where relevant, the building manager about your specific project.
When should you replace the charcoal filter?
How often you need to replace it depends on the filter and hood, not just on the recirculation mode. Elica publishes instructions for specific disposable filters, while Novy distinguishes between several generations of monoblock filters. Follow the instructions for the filter reference compatible with your appliance.
Is recirculation suitable for gas cooking?
Qualitel advises against using a recirculating cooker hood for gas cooking, as it doesn’t vent combustion pollutants outdoors. Before choosing this set-up, consider the type of hob, extraction options and ventilation in your home.