Joybuy Insights

Coloured Pencils: How to Choose the Right Set for Drawing, School or Creative Crafts

Choosing coloured pencils isn’t just about counting the shades on the box. A palette of 72 colours can quickly become impractical if the leads break, the storage doesn’t protect the tips properly, or the pigments aren’t suited to the technique you’re using.

For families, students, teachers and artists alike, three common pitfalls keep cropping up:

  • Confusing quantity with versatility: a large number of colours doesn’t guarantee better blends or more subtle gradients.
  • Overlooking the lead: if it’s too thin, it can snap under a child’s pressure; if it’s very soft, it’s less suitable for fine details.
  • Underestimating storage: a metal tin, a case or a roll each serves different needs at school, on the go or in the studio.

Here are the criteria to consider before buying a set of coloured pencils.

The factors to examine before buying

1. The shape and thickness of the lead

The diameter of the lead directly affects comfort and durability. Thick-lead pencils, such as the STABILO Trio with a 4.2 mm lead, are ideal for large areas and children who press hard. Their triangular shape also helps maintain a stable grip.

For detailed drawings, a finer, more resilient lead allows for precise outlines. Professional Faber-Castell Polychromos pencils feature, according to their product description, an oil-based 3.8 mm lead reinforced by an SV bonding process. This design reduces the risk of breakage and helps keep a fine point for longer.

Triangular coloured pencils also have the advantage of not rolling off the table. They are particularly practical for children, school activities and long colouring sessions.

2. The type of binder and compatible techniques

Standard pencils are suitable for dry colouring, hatching and layering. Oil-based pencils, like the Polychromos, are generally preferred for smooth blending and graphic details.

Watercolour pencils contain pigments that are soluble in water. Simply draw dry, then go over with a slightly damp brush to spread the colour. This technique does require paper that is thick enough to prevent warping.

Pastel pencils offer a more powdery, opaque texture. They can be blended with a finger or a blending stump, but finished works may need a fixative spray to reduce the risk of smudging. This type of pencil is mainly aimed at those who want to work with textures, backgrounds or effects similar to charcoal.

For children, the STABILO Woody 3-in-1 pencils combine the functions of a coloured pencil, a watercolour pencil and an oil pastel. Their 10 mm lead allows you to cover large areas quickly, but they are less suited to very fine details.

3. The number of colours and the type of storage

A set of 12 or 18 colours is enough for homework, everyday colouring and first drawings. A selection of 24 shades offers more variety without becoming too bulky. Sets of 36 to 72 colours are more suited to illustration, portraiture, landscape or regular practice.

Storage should be chosen according to how you’ll use them:

  • Metal tin: it protects the pencils well and is easy to carry in a bag.
  • Wooden case: it offers a neat presentation and organised storage for the studio.
  • Pencil roll: it gives quick access to the colours and is easy to transport.
  • Cardboard wallet: lightweight and compact, it’s often suitable for school or occasional use.

Also check whether a sharpener is included. Thick-lead pencils aren’t always compatible with a standard model.

Our selection based on your profile

Recommended for: Beginners on a budget
Maped Color'Peps Triangular Coloured Pencils Assorted 18 Colours

Maped Color'Peps Triangular Coloured Pencils Assorted 18 Colours

Why this choice suits this profile: With 18 shades, a triangular shape and a 2.9 mm lead, this set is ideal for first colouring sessions, school supplies and creative activities at home.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The number of colours is reasonable, so you’re not paying for shades you’ll rarely use. The durable lead is easy to sharpen, minimising interruptions during colouring.

Main advantage and key features

Triangular shape, 18 colours, FSC-certified wood and a lightweight cardboard wallet for easy carrying.

Recommended for: Premium enthusiasts
Faber-Castell POLYCHROMOS Coloured Pencils, 36-Count Studio Box

Faber-Castell POLYCHROMOS Coloured Pencils, 36-Count Studio Box

Why this choice suits this profile: With 36 oil-based shades, a 3.8 mm lead and an Atelierbox case, this set is designed for illustrators, art students and hobbyists who want precise blending.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The colour selection and oil-based binder prioritise blending and layering rather than simply accumulating colours.

Main advantage and key features

Pigments described as lightfast, SV lead, layering application and structured storage.

Recommended for: Specific uses and heavy users
Faber-Castell Watercolor Colored Pencils in a Metal Box 24 Pieces

Faber-Castell Watercolor Colored Pencils in a Metal Box 24 Pieces

Why this choice suits this profile: This set of 24 watercolour pencils lets you move from dry drawing to water washes, while remaining compact enough for classes, sketchbooks or travel.

How this product avoids the pitfall

It doesn’t limit you to dry colouring: its water solubility lets you explore an extra technique without buying more supplies.

Main advantage and key features

24 colours, water-soluble pigments, dry or wet use and a protective metal tin.

Recommended for: Children and frequent colouring
STABILO Trio Thick Colouring Pencils Assorted Colours, Pack of 24

STABILO Trio Thick Colouring Pencils Assorted Colours, Pack of 24

Why this choice suits this profile: Their chunky triangular barrel and 4.2 mm lead are designed for little hands and long colouring sessions, both at school and at home.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The thick lead reduces the risk of breakage when a child presses hard and allows large areas to be covered quickly.

Main advantage and key features

24 pencils, triangular barrel, 4.2 mm lead and wood from certified forests according to the product description.

Looking for other options?

We’ve put together a comprehensive, real-time updated list of products that fully meet these strict selection criteria and European safety regulations.

Frequently asked questions about coloured pencils

How many pencils do you need to get started?

A set of 12 to 24 colours generally covers school needs, colouring and first blending exercises. For portraiture, landscapes or detailed illustrations, 36 shades or more offer a more complete starting palette.

How can you extend the life of the pencils?

Use a sharpener that matches the diameter of the lead, without applying excessive pressure. Put the pencils back in their box or case after use and avoid damp places or direct sunlight. With watercolour pencils, wait until the surface is dry before storing them.

Are professional coloured pencils suitable for children?

They can be suitable for teenagers and adults who want to learn layering techniques, but their lead and price don’t always match the needs of younger children. For little hands, children’s coloured pencils with a triangular barrel and a thick lead are generally easier to handle. Products containing small parts should not be used by children under 3 years of age.