How to Choose the Perfect Coloured Pencil Set for Your Artwork

Choosing a box of coloured pencils might seem simple, but navigating the vast array of options can be overwhelming. Between oil-based, wax-based, or watercolour leads, and sets for beginners versus those for seasoned artists, it's easy to get lost. This guide is here to cut through the noise and help you select the tools that truly match your creative projects, free from marketing jargon.

As a product expert for our editorial team, my mission is to provide an objective analysis to help you make the right choice.

How to Choose the Right Coloured Pencils

Before diving into our top picks, let's review the key criteria that define a quality coloured pencil. Your choice will naturally depend on your skill level, the technique you're aiming for, and the desired final result.

1. Lead Type: Watercolour, Oil, or Wax?

The lead's composition is arguably the most important factor.

• Wax-Based Pencils: The most common and affordable option. They offer a smooth application and are great for blending. Be aware that they can leave a slight waxy residue (known as "wax bloom") if you apply too many layers.
• Oil-Based Pencils: These are primarily found in professional-grade coloured pencil lines. Their harder lead is perfect for detail work and precision. They saturate the paper less quickly than wax-based pencils and allow for excellent colour layering.
• Watercolour Pencils: The artist's Swiss Army knife! They can be used dry, like a standard pencil, but reveal their magic when water is added: the pigments dissolve and can be worked like paint. With a wet brushstroke, your drawing takes on a watercolour-like appearance.

2. Pigment Quality and Lightfastness

For artists who intend to sell or exhibit their work, lightfastness is a non-negotiable criterion. Professional-grade coloured pencil ranges usually display this lightfastness rating on the packaging or the pencil itself. High-quality pigments not only guarantee long-lasting colours but also their vibrancy and coverage on paper.

3. Intended Use: Hobby or Professional Project?

You wouldn't choose the same set for casual colouring as you would for a professional illustration. Student or hobbyist-grade sets are an excellent compromise for getting started. Artist-grade ranges, like the renowned Polychromos pencils, aim for far superior technical performance.

Recommended Coloured Pencil Picks

Now for our selection of products that tick all the boxes, whether you're a beginner or a seasoned artist.

Faber-Castell Set of 12 Watercolour Pencils + Brush

What sets it apart This Faber-Castell pencil set is all about versatility. It allows you to draw traditionally or create watercolour effects with the included brush. A perfect all-in-one solution for trying out mixed media without breaking the bank.

Pros

• Versatility: Allows you to switch between dry drawing and watercolour effects.
• Complete Kit: Includes 12 pencils and a brush, ready to use out of the box.
• Durable Lead: The leads are designed to withstand pressure, making them suitable for everyone, including younger users.
• Practicality: The compact tin fits anywhere.

Who is it for? Perfect for students, hobbyists, and artists on the go who want to get started with watercolour pencils using a reliable and portable kit.

Deli Wooden Coloured Pencils, Assorted Colours, 12-Piece Set

What sets it apart This 12-pencil set from Deli gets straight to the point: simplicity and an affordable price. It offers a palette of essential colours in a classic format, perfect for everyday needs, no frills attached.

Pros

• Functional: A selection of 12 vibrant colours, ideal for drawing, colouring, or school projects.
• Smooth Application: The pigments ensure a smooth and even laydown.
• Wooden Body: The wooden casing protects the lead well and sharpens easily with a standard sharpener.

Who is it for? The smart choice for beginners, for colouring afternoons (for adults or children), or for anyone looking for a simple and effective box of coloured pencils for occasional use.

Faber-Castell Polychromos Coloured Pencils, Tin of 12

What sets it apart Now we're entering the big leagues. Polychromos pencils are a true institution among professionals. Their rich, smooth oil-based lead delivers intense pigmentation and allows for layering without ever saturating the paper.

Pros

• Pigment Quality: Rich, vibrant colours with excellent lightfastness, for artwork that stands the test of time.
• Oil-Based Lead: Ideal for precision work, fine details, and subtle gradients.
• Break-Resistant: The lead is highly resistant to breaking, offering perfect control over your strokes.
• Metal Tin: The iconic metal tin provides excellent protection for the pencils.

Who is it for? A must-have for discerning artists, illustrators, and designers seeking high-performance drawing supplies for their finest work, whether it's portraits, landscapes, or detailed illustrations.

Looking for More Options?

Our selection highlights a few gems for every type of artist, but the world of drawing is endless. To explore a wider range, discover other brands, or find larger sets, feel free to browse our full category.

Discover All Our Artist Drawing Pencils

Frequently Asked Questions About Coloured Pencils

What's the difference between oil-based and wax-based pencils?

Wax-based pencils are softer, blend very well, and are perfect for colouring large, flat areas. Oil-based pencils have a harder lead, making them ideal for fine details, sharp lines, and layering multiple colours without the risk of a waxy buildup.

How do you use watercolour pencils?

Their dual nature is their greatest strength. First, use them dry, just like any other pencil. Then, to create the watercolour effect, simply go over your drawing with a wet brush. The pigments dissolve instantly to create washes and gradients. Remember to use a fairly thick paper (like watercolour paper) to prevent it from buckling from the water.

Is a 12-pencil set enough to get started?

Absolutely. A basic 12-colour set is actually ideal for beginners. It forces you to learn how to mix colours to create a wide range of shades yourself, which is a great learning experience. It's the perfect starting point to practice your skills before moving on to more comprehensive sets if you feel the need.