Homes with several rooms to clean
If you regularly give your home a thorough clean, check the capacity of the bag or bin, the operating radius and how often you’ll need to change sockets. UFC-Que Choisir recommends cylinder vacuums for larger homes.
Who is this guide for?
Homes with carpets, rugs, grooved wooden floors or pets
Performance on hard floors alone doesn’t tell you how well a vacuum will clean textiles or grooves. Compare test results for the surfaces you need to clean, and check which brush comes with the model you’re considering.
Buyers looking for a compact appliance
A cordless stick vacuum saves you from moving a cylinder around, but before choosing one as your main appliance, check its battery life at the setting you’ll use and how well it performs on your carpets. UFC-Que Choisir generally considers stick vacuums better suited to occasional use.
What should you look for?
Start with the floors you need to clean, then check whether the appliance can get through your planned cleaning without too many interruptions or demanding maintenance.
| What to consider | What to check | What I need |
|---|---|---|
| Carpets and pet hair | Look for vacuuming test results on carpets and rugs, particularly for dust and fibres. Check which brush is included with the version on sale. | I want to remove dust and fibres from textiles, not just pick up visible debris from the surface. |
| Wooden floors and mixed flooring | If your wooden floors have grooves, look for test results that cover them. Check which brushes are included and what settings are available for each floor type. | My rooms have a mix of hard floors and carpets, or gaps where dust can collect. |
| Cleaning without interruptions | For a stick vacuum, check its battery life in the mode you’ll use on carpets, not just its maximum quoted runtime. For a cylinder vacuum, compare the bag or bin capacity and operating radius. | I want to clean several rooms without having to recharge, empty the bin or change sockets repeatedly. |
| Dust and maintenance | Check how to empty the bin or replace the bag, as well as the filter type and maintenance requirements for the exact model. UFC-Que Choisir says bagged cylinder vacuums expose you to less dust during this process than bagless models. | Limiting contact with dust matters to me, and I also want an appliance that’s easy to maintain. |
| Moving and storage | Compare the weight, dimensions and storage position of the exact model. A robot vacuum also needs an accessible space to move around and be maintained. | I need to be able to move the vacuum between rooms and find a place to store it after use. |
Mistakes to avoid
-
Judging a vacuum by motor wattage alone
This figure alone doesn’t tell you how much dust or how many fibres a vacuum will pick up from a carpet. The brush and performance on the floor in question also matter.
Compare test results for the types of flooring in your home and check the accessories included with the model on sale, rather than choosing between two appliances based on wattage alone.
-
Confusing maximum battery life with carpet-cleaning time
The setting needed for a demanding surface can reduce a cordless stick vacuum’s runtime compared with its advertised maximum.
Check the runtime in the mode you plan to use, then compare it with the number of rooms you need to clean before choosing a stick vacuum as your main appliance.
-
Forgetting about bags and bin maintenance
A bagged cylinder vacuum needs compatible bags, while a bagless model needs its bin emptied. Filters and brushes also need appropriate care.
Check the reference for replacement consumables, along with the capacity and maintenance instructions for the model you’re considering.
-
Assuming a robot vacuum can replace a thorough clean
According to UFC-Que Choisir, robot vacuum performance varies depending on the floor and model. So, an automated clean doesn’t guarantee that your carpets will be cleaned to your satisfaction.
Consider a robot vacuum as an extra until its performance on your carpets, ability to move around your home and maintenance requirements meet your needs.
A few brands to consider
Electrolux
The Pure D8 range of bagged cylinder vacuums is worth comparing if capacity and operating radius matter when cleaning several rooms.
- Electrolux lists a 3,5 L bag and a 12 m operating radius for the Pure D8 model featured in its documentation.
- These specifications alone don’t tell you how well it will pick up dust from your carpets.
Rowenta
Some of the brand’s bagged cylinder vacuums are worth considering if capacity and moving between rooms are priorities.
- Rowenta lists a 4,5 L bag and a 12 m operating radius for the G-Force Silence RO6189EA.
- Check the accessories and specifications of the exact model on sale; one model’s details don’t apply to the whole range.
Bosch
The bagged ProAnimal BGB41PET1 could be worth comparing if pet hair is an important consideration.
- Bosch lists a 4,0 L bag and a turbo brush for this model.
- A turbo brush doesn’t replace test results for the carpets and textiles you need to clean.
A bagged cylinder vacuum on Joybuy
This bagged cylinder vacuum is designed for regular cleaning across several rooms. Compare its performance on your carpets and consider any practical requirements before choosing it as your main appliance.
Image unavailable
Electrolux 600 EB61C4OG bagged cylinder vacuum cleaner
This model is worth considering for regular cleaning across several rooms and carpets. Before choosing the EB61C4OG, compare its performance on your floor coverings, check which brushes are included and make sure you can get compatible bags.
Frequently asked questions
Can a cordless stick vacuum replace a cylinder vacuum for large carpets?
It can, provided the model you choose cleans your carpets well enough and lasts long enough at the required setting. UFC-Que Choisir generally considers stick vacuums better suited to occasional use and notes their common limitations on demanding surfaces. Check test results for the exact model before making it your only vacuum cleaner.
Bagged or bagless cylinder vacuum: which should you choose for carpets and pets?
A bagged model is a good choice if you want to limit contact with dust when replacing the dust collector: UFC-Que Choisir gives it the edge on this point and on vacuuming performance compared with the bagless cylinder vacuums in its guide. A bagless model is still worth considering if you’d rather avoid bags and don’t mind regularly emptying the bin and maintaining the filters.
Which brushes should you check before buying?
Check that the supplied brush is suitable for each of your floor types. If pet hair is a concern, look for a turbo brush designed for the textiles you need to clean. Check what’s included with the version on sale rather than assuming that an accessory shown for a range will always be included.
Is a robot vacuum enough for deep-cleaning carpets?
Don’t assume so: according to UFC-Que Choisir, robot vacuum performance varies depending on the floor and model. A robot can provide extra cleaning between thorough cleans, as long as its performance on your carpets and its maintenance requirements suit you.