Anyone following a specific recipe
If the consistency of your batter depends on the type of cream specified, check whether the recipe says ‘single’, ‘semi-thick’ or ‘thick’ before changing ingredients.
When baking a cake, start by checking which ingredient and texture the recipe calls for. If it asks for single cream, a pourable UHT cream may be suitable, but you can’t automatically replace semi-thick or thick crème fraîche with the same quantity. Long-life filtered milk is still milk, not cream; only use it instead if the recipe specifically allows for that substitution.
If the consistency of your batter depends on the type of cream specified, check whether the recipe says ‘single’, ‘semi-thick’ or ‘thick’ before changing ingredients.
UHT cream is a good option if you need a product that will keep for longer unopened. Check the pack size and storage instructions on the product you choose.
Cream explicitly labelled lactose-free may meet this requirement, as long as its consistency also suits the recipe. ‘Lactose-free’ does not mean ‘milk-free’.
First, check whether the recipe calls for milk or cream. If it asks for cream, match its consistency and product description to the recipe, and take your storage needs into account.
| What to consider | What to check | Who this matters to |
|---|---|---|
| Consistency required by the recipe | Whether it says ‘single’, ‘semi-thick’ or ‘thick’, and the ingredients list, particularly whether it contains starch or thickeners. | If my recipe calls for single cream in the batter, I want to avoid changing how it mixes in by using a different consistency. Around 42% of consumers would prioritise matching the specified consistency. |
| Storage before opening | The UHT label, pack size and storage instructions for before and after opening. | If I buy the cream before making my cake, I’m mainly looking for a product that can be stored unopened according to the instructions on its packaging. This would be the main concern for around 33% of consumers. |
| Lactose-free labelling | Clear lactose-free labelling, the stated lactose content, and whether milk appears in the ingredients or allergen information. | I’m primarily looking for cream labelled lactose-free, without assuming that it contains no milk. Around 25% of consumers would put this first. |
Président distinguishes crème fraîche from long-life cream, which is made using a sterilisation process. So a recipe specifying ‘thick crème fraîche’ doesn’t simply mean any carton of UHT cream.
Check the product description and consistency, then compare them with the wording in your recipe.
Semi-thick creams from Auchan and Carrefour contain ingredients such as starch or thickeners. Their consistency may not match the single cream specified for a cake batter.
If the recipe asks for single cream, choose that consistency or check that the recipe allows a substitute.
Auchan’s lactose-free single cream contains cream from milk. Its ‘lactose-free’ label does not mean it is a milk-free product.
If you need to avoid milk, check the ingredients and allergen information for the exact product separately.
The fact that milk is long-life doesn’t tell you whether it can replace cream in cake batter. These ingredients aren’t interchangeable just because they have that in common.
Before buying, check whether the recipe calls for milk or cream, and whether it specifically allows a substitution.
These ranges show some of the different consistencies and product descriptions to compare. The brand name is no substitute for checking the label of the product you choose.
The range includes a full-fat gastronomic crème fraîche with 30% fat, as well as long-life creams.
The range includes a full-fat, pourable UHT cream with 30% fat.
Full-fat UHT products with 30% fat are available in pourable, semi-thick and lactose-free versions.
The range includes full-fat semi-thick UHT cream with 30% fat, sold in 20 cl cartons.
Products listed by E.Leclerc include full-fat, pourable UHT creams with 30% fat, sold under the names SOUTENONS NOS AGRICULTEURS and DELISSE.
Not automatically. First check whether the recipe calls for single, semi-thick or thick cream. Président distinguishes crème fraîche from long-life UHT cream. For a specific recipe, also match the stated fat content, and only substitute an ingredient if the recipe allows it or you’ve checked that it will work in that recipe.
No, this isn’t a general rule for baking cakes. Use the type of cream specified in your recipe. Elle & Vire recommends a minimum fat content of 30% for whipping cream so that it holds its shape when whipped. That’s a different use from mixing cream into cake batter.
Follow the instructions on the packaging of the product you’ve bought and refrigerate it after opening as directed. The storage instructions and time limits given for Auchan products differ from those given by Président, so don’t apply guidance for one product to all creams.
No. The lactose-free cream featured by Auchan contains cream from milk. If you need to avoid milk, don’t rely on the ‘lactose-free’ label alone; check the ingredients and allergen information for the specific product.