For a household that regularly makes espresso and wants the freedom to choose its own beans, a bean-to-cup machine is worth comparing with portion-based systems. Que Choisir reports a lower cost per cup than with pod espresso, although the machine takes up more space and needs more maintenance. A capsule machine is a better fit if compactness and everyday convenience matter most; milk functions are only worth considering if you’ll actually use them.
If you often make espresso and want to choose your own beans, an integrated grinder can meet your needs. Compare its running costs with those of portion-based systems, and remember to factor in the space it takes up and the maintenance it requires.
If cappuccinos and lattes are part of your routine, look at the milk system and how it needs to be cleaned after use, rather than focusing only on the number of recipes listed.
If you have limited worktop space and want to keep handling to a minimum, a capsule machine may be a better fit. Be sure to check which capsule format it takes and how much it costs to use.
Que Choisir distinguishes between grinder, capsule, soft pod and portafilter machines. For regular use, your choice mainly depends on whether you want to use beans, how much preparation you’re happy to do and how much space you have available.
Worth considering: if you often make espresso and want to choose your own beans.
The trade-off: allow for more space, noise while the beans are ground and cleaning the parts you use.
Worth considering: if pre-measured portions and a compact machine matter more than choosing your own beans.
The trade-off: your options depend on the compatible capsule format, and you’ll pay for capsules with every cup.
Worth considering: if you want portion-based brewing without an integrated grinder.
The trade-off: compare the compatible pods and their running costs with the beans you’re considering.
Worth considering: if you want to be hands-on with preparing your espresso.
The trade-off: dosing, tamping and cleaning involve more steps; if you use beans, you’ll also need a grinder.
| Factor | What to check | Who it matters to |
|---|---|---|
| Running costs and choice of coffee | Compare your usual consumption with the coffee compatible with each system. For a grinder machine, check which grind settings you need. | I make espresso often and want to choose my own beans without overlooking the cost of each cup; around 36% of consumers would make this their top priority. |
| Everyday maintenance | Check how easy it is to reach the trays, the descaling process and, where applicable, how to clean the milk system. | I’d rather keep the steps after each coffee to a minimum and find it easy to maintain the machine; this would be the priority for around 29% of consumers. |
| Milk-based drinks | Check the recipes on the specific model, the type of milk system and what you’ll need to do after use. | We regularly make cappuccinos or lattes, and how the milk system works matters more to us than recipes we won’t use; around 21% of consumers would put this need first. |
| Space and noise | Measure the space where you’ll put the machine, then check how much room you’ll need to fill the water tank and remove the trays. Bear in mind the noise from grinding. | My kitchen has limited space, or the grinder would disturb others at home; this would be the main consideration for around 14% of consumers. |
A milk carafe, profiles and extra programmes offer little to a household that rarely uses them. The milk system also means extra cleaning.
Make a note of the drinks you actually prepare, then compare the settings and how easy it is to reach the parts that need cleaning on the models you’re considering.
With frequent use, beans and portions can work out at different costs per cup. In its guide, Que Choisir says that a bean-to-cup espresso costs two to three times less per cup than pod espresso.
Work it out using the number of cups you usually make and the beans, capsules or pods you would actually buy.
Water hardness and how often you use the machine affect how much maintenance it needs. Capsule machines also need to be descaled.
Before choosing, check the instructions for the model and find out how it alerts you when descaling is due, as well as whether you might need a filter.
You need to be able to reach a bean-to-cup machine to add water and beans and remove the trays. Que Choisir also points out that it takes up more space than a capsule system.
Compare the dimensions of the exact model with the space you have, leaving enough room to open the lids and remove any parts.
The bean-to-cup range includes the Magnifica, Dinamica, Eletta and PrimaDonna families, with drinks and milk systems varying by model.
Philips bean-to-cup machines with LatteGo may appeal to households that make milk-based drinks and value an easy-to-clean carafe.
The range lets you compare espresso-focused machines such as Purista with models offering more recipes, such as Barista SE.
Nespresso machines are worth comparing if you prefer capsules to choosing your own beans.
These models feature an integrated grinder. Compare their variations and the steps involved before choosing: capsule, pod and portafilter systems are other possible answers to the same question.
Image unavailable
Worth considering if you want an automatic machine for making espresso regularly from beans. The listed bundle also includes Lavazza Tales of Napoli & Roma coffee, 450 g (2 packs); check the exact bundle contents before ordering.
Image unavailable
Worth a look if you want to use beans and make milk-based drinks too: this model is listed as having LatteGo. Check the recipes available on the EP2230/10 and whether its milk-cleaning routine suits you.
Image unavailable
Worth comparing if you want to grind beans in the machine and have a listed 2.8 L water tank. The model name specifies a dual boiler and a 20-bar pump, but the stated pressure alone isn’t enough to judge the coffee in the cup; also check the maintenance instructions.
Image unavailable
This bean-to-cup machine is an option to compare if you regularly make espresso. Check the space needed to open the lids and remove the trays; follow the model’s instructions for maintenance and descaling.
Image unavailable
Worth considering for making espresso from beans; the model also has a filter coffee function, which is separate from choosing an espresso system. Check which milk frother is included, as well as the space it takes up and the maintenance steps that suit your needs.
There’s no single threshold that works for every household: it depends on how much coffee you drink and what you’d choose to buy. Que Choisir says a bean-to-cup espresso costs two to three times less per cup than pod espresso; compare this guidance with your usual purchases and the maintenance required by the machines you’re considering.
Follow the instructions and alerts for your model, taking the hardness of your water into account. De’Longhi highlights the latter factor for its bean-to-cup machines; for its own machines, Nespresso recommends descaling every 3 months or after around 300 capsules. This schedule doesn’t apply to all grinder machines.
No. A carafe can make some steps easier, but the milk system still needs to be maintained according to the instructions. Before buying, check what rinsing is required after use, which parts can be removed and how they should be washed for the model you’re considering.
For aluminium or plastic capsules, ADEME says to put them in the sorting bin, bag or container for paper and packaging. If what happens to used portions matters to you, also check the disposal guidance for the material of the capsules you plan to use.