Joybuy Insights

Art markers and colouring pencils: how to choose the right materials for every project

Choosing art markers and colouring pencils isn’t just about counting how many colours come in a set. Between promises of intense pigmentation, “versatile” tips and inks said to work on every surface, some purchases can quickly turn out to be disappointing or impractical.

To avoid unpleasant surprises, it’s worth looking at the type of ink, the shape of the tip, the compatible surfaces and the age of the user. Here are the criteria to consider when comparing different options and selecting materials suited to drawing, journaling, watercolour or creative hobbies.

Common pitfalls before you buy

1. Confusing the number of colours with versatility

A set of 72 coloured pencils might seem more comprehensive than a pack of 18 markers, but that doesn’t mean they meet the same needs. Pencils are better suited to gradual work, hatching and dry blending. Acrylic markers, on the other hand, lay down a more opaque colour on surfaces like wood, glass or ceramic.

Before comparing quantities, first identify the technique you want to use: colouring on paper, illustration, watercolour, customising objects or a creative activity for children.

2. Thinking one tip can do everything

A fine tip makes it easy to draw outlines and details, but it covers large areas slowly. A chisel tip lets you fill in more quickly, while a brush tip varies the line thickness depending on the pressure you apply. Dual-tip markers save you from constantly switching tools – provided both ends actually suit your needs.

The flexibility of a brush tip also takes a little practice to master. For children and beginners, a sturdy tip and a body that’s easy to hold can be far more practical.

3. Overlooking the surface and drying time

A water-based ink won’t give the same result on ordinary paper as it will on watercolour paper. Watercolour markers and watercolour brush pens let you create blending effects with a damp brush, but paper that’s too thin may buckle or let moisture bleed through.

With paint markers, always test the product on a small area when working on a non-porous or delicate surface. The phrase “water-resistant” doesn’t guarantee the result will withstand outdoor use or repeated rubbing.

Technical criteria to check

The type of ink

  • Water-based ink: suitable for drawing, colouring, journaling and watercolour effects. It’s generally easier to clean up, but it can bleed through thin paper.
  • Watercolour ink: designed to be diluted or moved with water on a suitable surface. The amount of liquid and the quality of the paper strongly influence the final result.
  • Acrylic ink: more opaque, it’s often chosen for acrylic markers and projects on wood, glass, stone, metal, plastic or canvas. It can dry permanently and stain clothing.
  • Pencil lead: coloured pencils offer precise control and allow you to layer shades gradually. Watercolour pencils add the option of transforming the line with a damp brush.

Don’t assume lightfastness or waterproofness just from the colour stated. Check the product details and the usage conditions provided by the manufacturer.

The tip and diameter

When comparing drawing markers, look at the shape and width of the tip:

  • Fine tip: details, outlines, writing and intricate patterns.
  • Bullet tip: consistent lines, everyday colouring and filling moderate areas.
  • Chisel tip: fine or broad strokes depending on the angle you use.
  • Brush tip: lettering, illustration and expressive variations.
  • Dual tip: a handy combination of a fine end and a brush or broad end.

The diameter of the body is also worth your attention. XXL lead pencils or short, chunky models are easier for small hands to hold, while a slimmer tool may be better for details and long drawing sessions.

The number of colours and accessories

A worthwhile set of art markers should offer a palette that matches your habits. Pastel shades can be useful for bullet journals and portraits, whereas highly opaque colours are better suited to customisation.

Also check what accessories are included: a suitable sharpener, a brush, a rigid case or a metal tin. These make storage, transport and maintenance easier, but they shouldn’t distract you from a palette that’s poorly suited to your projects.

Which option for your profile?

Recommended for: Beginners on a budget
STABILO Woody 3-in-1 Colouring Set - 18 Pack

STABILO Woody 3-in-1 – set of 18

Why this choice suits this profile: This set combines the functions of a coloured pencil, a watercolour pencil and a wax crayon, with a sharpener and a brush included. It’s suitable for a wide range of creative activities, at home and at school.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The versatility is clearly defined: one pencil lets you practise three techniques and can be used on paper, card or certain smooth, wipe-clean surfaces.

Main advantage and key features

18 colours, XXL 10 mm lead, PEFC-certified wood and accessories included.

Recommended for: High-end enthusiasts
Faber-Castell Albrecht Dürer Watercolour Marker Wallet of 30

Faber-Castell Albrecht Dürer – wallet of 30 watercolour markers

Why this choice suits this profile: Artists who switch between sketching, illustration and mixed media get two tips per marker and a water-based ink designed to be worked with a damp brush.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product details specify a flexible brush tip and a fine tip, rather than claiming vague versatility.

Main advantage and key features

30 shades, water-soluble ink, wallet-style case and good stated lightfastness.

Recommended for: Specific uses and heavy users
Ohuhu 48 PCS Acrylic Paint Pens

Ohuhu – 48 acrylic paint markers

Why this choice suits this profile: This set is aimed at DIY projects, decorating objects and personalising a variety of surfaces, with two tip sizes available in the same colours.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The stated compatibility is detailed: paper, wood, stone, glass, ceramic, plastic and fabric. A prior test is still recommended depending on the surface.

Main advantage and key features

48 markers, 24 fine tips of 0.7 mm and 24 reversible round or chisel tips.

Recommended for: Journaling and adult colouring
Sharpie Acrylic Paint Markers Brush Tip

Sharpie – acrylic paint markers with brush tip

Why this choice suits this profile: The brush tip works well for colouring pages, lettering and lines of varying thickness. The palette of 12 warm tones is also easy to organise.

How this product avoids the pitfall

The product details specify the different compatible surfaces and recommend horizontal storage – two pieces of information often missing from overly general descriptions.

Main advantage and key features

Water-based acrylic ink, flexible brush tip and the ability to layer colours once the first coat is dry.

Looking for other options?

We’ve put together a comprehensive, real-time selection of products that meet these selection criteria as well as European safety regulations.

Care and lifespan

The lifespan of a marker or pencil depends mainly on how often you use it, the surface you work on and how you store it. To keep your art materials in good condition:

  • replace every cap immediately after use;
  • store markers according to the manufacturer’s instructions, often horizontally;
  • use paper that’s suitable for wet inks;
  • avoid heat, excessive humidity and direct light;
  • choose a sharpener that matches the diameter of your pencils.

For acrylic markers, shake the product when the manufacturer recommends it and prime the tip on a scrap sheet. Do not use them on skin or on surfaces intended for food contact, unless the manufacturer explicitly states it and it complies with the intended use.

Frequently asked questions

Which markers should I choose for adult colouring?

Fine-tip markers are good for detailed patterns, while brush tips let you vary line thickness and fill larger areas more quickly. To minimise bleeding, choose paper that’s thick enough and check whether the ink shows through the pages.

Do watercolour pencils require special paper?

They can be used dry on ordinary paper, but watercolour paper will handle the addition of water much better. Start with a small amount of liquid and let it dry between layers to limit warping.

How can I stop markers from drying out too quickly?

Replace the cap immediately after use and make sure it’s fully closed. Also follow the recommended storage method. A case or metal tin helps protect the tips and keeps colours easy to see between sessions.