How do an air fryer and an oven compare?
Add an air fryer
Worth considering: for frequent small meals or crisp reheating, if the basket can hold the portion you want and you have space for the appliance.
The trade-off: the cooking compartment may mean you need several batches. You’ll also need to put up with the fan noise and clean an extra appliance.
Stick with your oven
Best for: larger dishes or meals you can cook together, especially if there isn’t room in your kitchen for another appliance.
The trade-off: for some small recipes, tests by UFC-Que Choisir found that the oven used more electricity than the air fryers tested. The difference depends on the food and the appliances being compared.
To decide whether an air fryer would add anything to your oven, start with the recipes you make most often. Then compare the portion it can cook at once, the space the appliance takes up and what it’s like to use.
| Criteria |
What to check before buying |
What matters to consumers |
| Useful for small portions |
Think about the small meals you cook often and check whether the basket can cook them all at once. |
For my small meals, I’d like to avoid switching on the full-size oven without adding an appliance that duplicates what I already have. Around 29% of consumers would put this usefulness first. |
| Usable capacity |
Compare the size of your food and dishes with the basket; if you’re considering a model with two baskets, check each compartment separately. |
Being able to serve everyone matters more to me if a small load means cooking in several batches. Avoiding repeat batches would be the top priority for around 23% of consumers. |
| Space and noise |
Measure the available space, the clearance needed to open the drawer and the distances specified in the instructions. Look for a noise measurement taken from a stated distance. |
In an open-plan or cluttered kitchen, I don’t want another appliance to get in the way of cooking or conversation. Around 18% of consumers would prioritise space and low noise. |
| Energy use per recipe |
Compare tests using the same recipe and quantity, taking any additional batches into account. |
If I often cook the same small meals, I want to compare the electricity used to cook the whole meal, not rely on a general claim. Around 18% of consumers would put this first. |
| Cleaning and aftercare |
Check which parts can be removed and are dishwasher-safe, as well as the seller’s aftercare terms. |
After frequent use, I’d prefer an easy-to-clean basket and clear aftercare terms. Around 12% of consumers would put these factors first. |
If deep-fat frying is your priority, a traditional deep-fat fryer serves a different purpose from an air fryer, and you’ll need to consider the oil, smells and cleaning the bowl. If you mainly switch between defrosting, reheating and convection cooking, compare the features of a combination microwave with those of the appliances you already own.
Joybuy products related to this choice
Products related to this topic will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
Can an air fryer replace an oven for everyday meals?
Not for every meal. An air fryer is best suited to frequent small portions that fit in its basket, while an oven is still handy for larger dishes and quantities you can cook together. Before replacing an oven for a particular use, count how many batches an air fryer would need.
How do I choose a capacity that suits my meals?
Compare your food and dishes with the dimensions or load examples given for the specific model, rather than looking at the litre capacity alone. Moulinex says a 24 cm pizza fits in the 7.5 L Easy Fry Compact EZ866HF1. The Philips NA461/00 has a stated capacity of 10 L, split between two 5 L baskets.
Does air fryer noise matter in an open-plan kitchen?
Yes. Fan noise can matter in an open-plan kitchen and varies by model. UFC-Que Choisir measures it from 50 cm away in its tests, so look for a result measured at a stated distance before you choose.
What should I check to make everyday cleaning easier?
Check the instructions to see which parts can be removed and put in the dishwasher, and how to care for their coatings. For its air fryers, Philips recommends, among other things, letting the appliance cool for around 30 minutes before cleaning and avoiding metal utensils on non-stick parts.
What statutory guarantee applies to an air fryer bought in France?
According to the DGCCRF, the statutory guarantee of conformity applies to new, second-hand and refurbished goods sold by a trader to a consumer in France. Keep the product description and proof of purchase so you can establish the features agreed with the seller.